Anarchy99 said:
LBH said:
What's his record without Brady? Give any coach the best QB of all time and sure he will be great. He's a good coach that's about it
So does that mean that all multi time SB winning coaches were nothing without their HOF QBs? I guess the coaches of the 49ers, Cowboys, Steelers, and the like we're only "good coaches" because they all had HOF QBs.
I would have to see what they did without their HOF QBs. Never said BB was "nothing" I said he was a good coach. I just think he gets way too much credit
Since you asked . . .
Multi-time SB winning coaches with and without HOF QBs (regular season records).
Belichick with Brady: 160-47-0 (.773)
Belichick without Brady: 51-62-0 (.451)
Noll with Bradshaw: 107-51-0 (.677)
Noll without Bradshaw: 86-91-1 (.470)
Walsh with Montana: 75-36-0 (.677)
Walsh without Montana: 17-23-1 (.427)
Shula with Unitas, Griese, or Marino: 269-127-5 (.677)
Shula without Unitas, Griese, or Marino: 59-29-1 (.669)
Landry with Staubach: 85-29-0 (.746)
Landry without Staubach: 165-133-6 (.554)
Shanahan with Elway: 43-16-0 (729)
Shanahan without Elway: 127-122-0 (.510)
Seifert with Montana or Young: 87-26-0 (770)
Seifert withour Montana or Young: 27-36-0 (429)
Lombardi with Starr: 77-23-4 (.760)
Lombardi without Starr: 19-11-2 (.625)
Jimmy Johnson with Aikman: 38-30-0 (.559)
Jimmy Johnson without Aikman: 42-34-0 (.553)
And if you think Eli is HOF worthy . . .
Coughlin with Eli: 91-76-0 (.545)
Coughlin without Eli: 73-64-0 (.533)