In Superflex Dynasty, trade my 1.03 for J.J. McCarthy? (1 Viewer)

[KingJombi]

My other 2 QB's are Jalen Hurtz and Kirk Cousiins. I think he's better than any of the incoming rookie QB's and he is in a good system.

 

[Gally]

If you are a believer it is a solid offer and worth doing unless you have holes elsewhere or a coveted player that you think is a cornerstone that you could get at 1.03. I haven't really started my research yet on the draft class to know what I would be looking at for pick 1.03.

I like JJM and probably pull that trigger

 

[FWmaker]

Tough to give up 1.03, but I think it's worth it. Especially this year. I'm about to post a trade offer to the forum - check it out when you can

 

[Crippler]

I own JJ in SF and don’t accept that offer. But 15 teamer. I laugh at owner that needs a QB and gave Caleb Williams for pick that was 1.1 at the time but ended 1.4 and than 2.1 pick than was 2.4 and 26 2nd. I would want 1-9-2.1 and 2nd back at miminum if that owner

 

[Hurl Bruce]

I'm a McCarthy skeptic. I didn't see his play in college and think that kids is going to be good in the NFL. He was a game manager in college, and was never really asked to make pro-level throws on a consistent basis. But that might be the Buckeye in me talking. IDK. They didn't win the championship because of him. They won due to Corum and Conner S.

 

[rockaction]

But that might be the Buckeye in me talking

Before I got to this it was what I was thinking of your comment given your user name. Sorry, but the OSU/Michigan rivalry seems to do it to people. Then again, you also follow him more than the average.

I personally don’t think the 1.03 gets it done here. You’re essentially thinking Jeanty then who? Sanders or Ward? I don’t trade McCarthy if he’s on my roster for either of those two guys, guys I won’t even get my choice of. No thanks. The drop off is so steep, I’d want another mid-1st for him. That’s what scarcity does, you know?

Caveat my own analysis and that is that my experience is 1QB. But I watch all the trades and this seems too light.

 

[lsutigers]

I'm a McCarthy skeptic. I didn't see his play in college and think that kids is going to be good in the NFL. He was a game manager in college, and was never really asked to make pro-level throws on a consistent basis. But that might be the Buckeye in me talking. IDK. They didn't win the championship because of him. They won due to Corum and Conner S.

I'm of the same mind. He received a ton of good press leading up to the draft but he was pretty far back from the other rookies. Maye and Nix performed well better than expected but even in a good situation, hard to think he'll come in with his limited skill set and perform as well as those guys.

I took over an orphaned team in a 16 team non SF league (where 3rd stringers are regularly rostered) and I can't give him away for a 2025 1st.