In your opinion... (1 Viewer)

[MaddHatter]

Simply put... should Shane Victorino make the NL All-Star team. Not just as a starter, not just as a reserve... but should he flat out be in the Bronx, wearing a NL uniform for the all-star game. Is he worthy?

In 51 games... he is batting .291, .365 OBP, .408 SLUG, 41 R, 57 H/196 AB, 17 RBI, 13 SB.

Complete Stats: http://www.baseball-reference.com/v/victosh01.shtml

He just carried the Phillies on his back to a sweep of the Braves and is arguably one of the top OF's in the national league.

Yay or Nay?

I am filling out my ballot and came across this tough decision. Ludwick, McLouth, Victorino, Braun, Soriano, Beltran?

I think I know who I am leaning on.

 

[Spartans Rule]

No way.

He's a nice fantasy player because he steals bases and bats before Chase Utley and Ryan Howard, but a .773 OPS in the outfield is not all-star worthy.

He is a good fielder, but not as good as Beltran, who even in a down year has comparable offensive stats to Victorino.

 

[MotivationalPoster]

Simply put... should Shane Victorino make the NL All-Star team. Not just as a starter, not just as a reserve... but should he flat out be in the Bronx, wearing a NL uniform for the all-star game. Is he worthy?

In 51 games... he is batting .291, .365 OBP, .408 SLUG, 41 R, 57 H/196 AB, 17 RBI, 13 SB.

Complete Stats: http://www.baseball-reference.com/v/victosh01.shtml

He just carried the Phillies on his back to a sweep of the Braves and is arguably one of the top OF's in the national league.

Yay or Nay?

I am filling out my ballot and came across this tough decision. Ludwick, McLouth, Victorino, Braun, Soriano, Beltran?

I think I know who I am leaning on.

hopefully you wrote it quentin on the AL side...

 

[Cool in the pocket]

Can't speak to the defensive side, but Braun and MClouth both have superior numbers and alot of Victorino's numbers stem from being in the middle of the Philly lineup.

 

[pollardsvision]

Simply put... should Shane Victorino make the NL All-Star team. Not just as a starter, not just as a reserve... but should he flat out be in the Bronx, wearing a NL uniform for the all-star game. Is he worthy?

In 51 games... he is batting .291, .365 OBP, .408 SLUG, 41 R, 57 H/196 AB, 17 RBI, 13 SB.

Complete Stats: http://www.baseball-reference.com/v/victosh01.shtml

He just carried the Phillies on his back to a sweep of the Braves and is arguably one of the top OF's in the national league.

Yay or Nay?

I am filling out my ballot and came across this tough decision. Ludwick, McLouth, Victorino, Braun, Soriano, Beltran?

I think I know who I am leaning on.

he's having a nice season, but there are too many people having better seasons.the 4 bolded above plus jason bay, carlos lee, pat burrell, ryan church just to name 8.

 

[Doctor Detroit]

The guy just started hitting the other day. I'd probably write in Spartans Rule before I voted for Victorino.

 

[shadyridr]

lopsided poll so far

 

[Spartans Rule]

The guy just started hitting the other day. I'd probably write in Spartans Rule before I voted for Victorino.

Seriously, I should be voted in as the All-Star fantasy owner the way I'm killing the FBG league.

 

[MAC_32]

Better fantasy player than real player, no All Star.

 

[shadyridr]

The guy just started hitting the other day. I'd probably write in Spartans Rule before I voted for Victorino.

Seriously, I should be voted in as the All-Star fantasy owner the way I'm killing the FBG league.

Seriously