So many more factors played into the teams record than just QB play.
The most notable being Denver's improved Defense in 09. In 08 they gave up 28 points a game, in 09 20 points a game. So on average Cutler had to lead two additional scoring drives a game to maintain the same record.
yeah, when you continually give the ball back to the other team they tend to score more.actually, I think I might've just figured him out ---- when you've got a pretty big lead the coach might pull you late in games, or just eat the clock handing the ball off, but if the other team were to keep scoring you need to keep throwing, thus pimping your stats, thus ca-ching! on your next contract.
cutler might just be smarter than the average bear.

Keep fishing...you don't like Cutler...we get it.
what I actually don't like is this rampant attitude in society that there's always a fall guy to blame, and we never need be held responsible for ourselves.
It's a team game all 11 of them have to work together to be successful.
cutler could throw the ball to the other team for ten more years, produce .500 records another decade, and people will still make excuses for him and blame the defense.
So you're going to assume what people opposite of you think....can't wait for this.
so, what I will do is undertake a little study of his picks last year.........
week - margin of victory/loss
yardline opponent's drive started on after pick - resulting points from drive
(drives starting inside chicago's 40 are in
RED)
W1 - 6 pt loss
opp 43 - 0
opp 14 - (-2)
own 1 - 7
own 14 - 0
W2 - 3 pt win
none
W3 - 6 pt win
opp 15 - 3
W4 - 24 pt win
none
W5 - BYE
W6 - 7 pt loss
opp 14 - 0
opp 45 - 7
W7 - 35 pt loss
own 17 - 3
opp 39 - 7
opp 47 - 7
W8 - 24 pt win
own 34 - 0
W9 - 20 pt loss
own 17 - 7
W10 - 4 pt loss
opp 11 - 0
own 14 - 7
opp 45 - 0
own 44 - 3
W11 - 4 pt loss
50 - 0
W12 - 26 pt loss
opp 20 - 0
opp 30 - 7
W13 - 8 pt win
none
W14 - 7 pt loss
own 39 - 3
own 11 - 7
W15 - 24 pt loss
opp 48 - 7
opp 19 - 7
opp 28 - 0
own 37 - 0
W16 - 6 pt win
opp 47 - 3
W17 - 14 pt win
none
that's a total of 26 picks leading to drives that produced a total of 83 points.
chicago finished 21st in the league in points allowed with 375.
cincy finished 6th at 291 points allowed, which happens to be just 84 points fewer.
what a difference 26 picks make.