Keep 8 from this list - 5x5 h2h (1 Viewer)

[Tiger Fan]

10 team, 5x5 h2h league. I need to keep 8. 4SP/5RP, 1 of every position player + 1 DH

Bolded who I would keep if i had to decide today. Pretty sure about the top 6, but not sure about Rolen/Pheralta. I need help

Ankiel,Rick

Bay,Jason

Bell,Heath

Braun,Ryan Z.

Broxton,Jonathan

Buchholz,Clay

Cust,Jack

DiNardo,Lenny

Drew,J.D.

Glavine,Tom

Guerrier,Matt

Hafner,Travis

Hudson,Orlando

Lee,Carlos N.

Linebrink,Scott

Marmol,Carlos

Martinez,Pedro

Molina,Bengie

Neshek,Pat

Oswalt,Roy

Pence,Hunter

Peralta,Jhonny

Price,David

Rolen,Scott

Schilling,Curt

Sheets,Ben

Sheffield,Gary

Spilborghs,Ryan

Theriot,Ryan

Wigginton,Ty

Wood,Brandon

Young,Chris R.

 

[ScottNorwood]

Hafner

Lee

Oswalt

Pence

Sheffield

Bay

Young

Martinez

 

[guru_007]

how long can you keep them for?

If it's just one year, I'd keep:

Oswalt

Lee

Pence

Drew

Pedro

Sheffield

Hafner

Bay

Just missing out Cust, Young, Hudson

 

[Tiger Fan]

how long can you keep them for?If it's just one year, I'd keep:OswaltLeePenceDrewPedroSheffieldHafnerBayJust missing out Cust, Young, Hudson

keep forever

 

[ScottNorwood]

how long can you keep them for?If it's just one year, I'd keep:OswaltLeePenceDrewPedroSheffieldHafnerBayJust missing out Cust, Young, Hudson

keep forever

In that case, replace Pedro with Bucholz on my list

 

[ooofffaaa]

No brainers:

Braun

Hafner

Lee

Pence

Young

Should be closing for their teams in a year or two:

Broxton

Neshek

Should have a spot in the rotation as early as this year:

Buchholz

Rolen is done. I'm a big fan but he's just about done.

 

[Bobcat10]

No brainers:

Braun

Hafner

Lee

Pence

Young

Should be closing for their teams in a year or two:

Broxton

Neshek

Should have a spot in the rotation as early as this year:

Buchholz

Rolen is done. I'm a big fan but he's just about done.

This is the pitcher Ryan Z Braun, not hitter Ryan J Braun.

 

[Bobcat10]

Bay

Hafner

Lee

Pence

Oswalt

Young

Buchholz

Sheffield

The only reason not Peralta over Sheffield is because it's a 10 team league. Lots of good SS between 8 and 14. Hudson is close too, but I'd drop him back in.

 

[ooofffaaa]

No brainers:

Braun

Hafner

Lee

Pence

Young

Should be closing for their teams in a year or two:

Broxton

Neshek

Should have a spot in the rotation as early as this year:

Buchholz

Rolen is done. I'm a big fan but he's just about done.

This is the pitcher Ryan Z Braun, not hitter Ryan J Braun.

ahhhThen substitute Bay for Braun.

 

[MrPhoenix]

Almost like Cust over Rolen here. I'm with ooofffaaa, Rolen's about done.

 

[ooofffaaa]

To put the dimished value of Rolen into perspective . . .

I'm currently in a 12 team redraft league with fairly knowledgable owners and we are in the 20th rd of the draft.

Scott Rolen is still available.

 

[Tiger Fan]

We're up to 12 teams this year, and I get to keep Buchholz as a rookie (doesn't count against my 8). So right now I'm looking at:

Hafner

Sheffield

Bay

Lee

Pence

Oswalt

Young

Sheets/Pedro

 

[Pnishthm]

We're up to 12 teams this year, and I get to keep Buchholz as a rookie (doesn't count against my 8). So right now I'm looking at:HafnerSheffieldBayLeePenceOswaltYoungSheets/Pedro

Your keepers here look fine but why the heck would you not keep Price? The guy is gonne be really good and it may even be this year.

 

[Bobcat10]

We're up to 12 teams this year, and I get to keep Buchholz as a rookie (doesn't count against my 8). So right now I'm looking at:HafnerSheffieldBayLeePenceOswaltYoungSheets/Pedro

Your keepers here look fine but why the heck would you not keep Price? The guy is gonne be really good and it may even be this year.

Building on this......how many "rookies" do you get to keep that are not part of the 8 regular keepers? In my previous post here, I had those 8 keepers except Buchholz over Sheets/Pedro.......I'd still do that AND keep Price.

 

[Pnishthm]

We're up to 12 teams this year, and I get to keep Buchholz as a rookie (doesn't count against my 8). So right now I'm looking at:HafnerSheffieldBayLeePenceOswaltYoungSheets/Pedro

Your keepers here look fine but why the heck would you not keep Price? The guy is gonne be really good and it may even be this year.

Building on this......how many "rookies" do you get to keep that are not part of the 8 regular keepers? In my previous post here, I had those 8 keepers except Buchholz over Sheets/Pedro.......I'd still do that AND keep Price.

This is exactly what I would do.

 

[Tiger Fan]

We're up to 12 teams this year, and I get to keep Buchholz as a rookie (doesn't count against my 8). So right now I'm looking at:HafnerSheffieldBayLeePenceOswaltYoungSheets/Pedro

Your keepers here look fine but why the heck would you not keep Price? The guy is gonne be really good and it may even be this year.

I get to keep Price, Buchholz and Wood as rookies (sorry i didn't clarify earlier)

 

[MrPhoenix]

I like Cust > Sheffield, but otherwise it looks fine.