Keeper help, pick 3 of 5 (1 Viewer)

[Hurler1]

12 Team, max keep 3

Start: 1 QB, 2 RB, 2WR, 2 R/W/T, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 TD

Standard PPR scoring

Picking 9th in 3rd round reversal draft (1-12, 12-1, 12-1, then snake). Do not have a 2nd round pick due to trade last year.

Pick 3 of 5, round listed is round they cost me:
M. Pittman, round 3 (pick 28)
J. Connors, round 5 (pick 52)
J. Hurts, round 6 (pick 69)
S. Barkley, round 7 (pick 76)
R. Stevenson, round 10 (pick 117)

I'll save my thoughts so as not to influence anyone's thinking.

 

[Keith R]

Conner is the lock. Barkley is the next-best bang-for-the-buck pick based on ADP. I'll lean towards Stevenson for the 3rd, as the other two could likely fall to the draft spot they would cost. Not a diverse cast but under your lineup rules, you can at least start them all at once.

I'll note that I would consider Barkley for a sign-and-trade situation for a high-level WR

 

[Rubi]

Pittman,Hurts,Stevenson for me

 

[tips88]

I tend to go for high ceilings and lots of upside (sometimes to my detriment!). I like Pittman and Stevenson for a 3rd and 10th. For me, the next choice is either high ceiling with signifivant risk (Barkley) or high floor (Connors). I like to swing for the fences so I would keep Barkley.

 

[Hurler1]

Conner is the lock. Barkley is the next-best bang-for-the-buck pick based on ADP. I'll lean towards Stevenson for the 3rd, as the other two could likely fall to the draft spot they would cost. Not a diverse cast but under your lineup rules, you can at least start them all at once.

I'll note that I would consider Barkley for a sign-and-trade situation for a high-level WR

I kinda had Conner and Barkley as locks. Leaning Pittman, only because I like him a lot this year and afraid he won't be there when I make my 3rd round pick. (with 20 - 30 keepers every year, ADP is a round or two higher than a straight redraft league.) Lot of support for Stevenson out here, so may have to reconsider.

 

[Gally]

Conner and Barkley are the no doubters. Depending on if other teams keep QB's that would influence the next pick. If everyone keeps a QB then I lean Hurts. If that is not the case I go with Stephenson.