Kinsler or pedroia? (1 Viewer)

[dundeeslugger]

Pedroia has done decent filling in for Kinsler but with Kinsler hopefully coming back off the DL on Tuesday do put him back in there right away?

Kinsler goes @ CLE and @ Tor

Pedroia vs BAL @ SEA

1 per base, 1run, 1rbi, 1sb, 1bb, -1 ko

 

[Mr. Know-It-All]

Can't answer your question but I had a choice between the two last week and went with Pedroia only because he was playing and Kinsler wasn't back yet.

Pedroia might be the safer pick, but Kinsler offers more upside this year with power and sb potential.

 

[dundeeslugger]

Can't answer your question but I had a choice between the two last week and went with Pedroia only because he was playing and Kinsler wasn't back yet. Pedroia might be the safer pick, but Kinsler offers more upside this year with power and sb potential.

wow, you know what, I went witht he same decision last week. It does make the decision somewhat easier when a guy is on the dl. Oh my.

 

[tikigods]

Pedroia has done decent filling in for Kinsler but with Kinsler hopefully coming back off the DL on Tuesday do put him back in there right away?Kinsler goes @ CLE and @ TorPedroia vs BAL @ SEA1 per base, 1run, 1rbi, 1sb, 1bb, -1 ko

Kinsler has been sucking since his hot April. I'm in the same situation and I'm sticking with Pedroia. The only concern are Dustin's ribs but he played yesterday so all looks good.

 

[Mr. Know-It-All]

Can't answer your question but I had a choice between the two last week and went with Pedroia only because he was playing and Kinsler wasn't back yet. Pedroia might be the safer pick, but Kinsler offers more upside this year with power and sb potential.

wow, you know what, I went witht he same decision last week. It does make the decision somewhat easier when a guy is on the dl. Oh my.

In my case though I don't have weekly transactions, whichever one I pick is stuck to my lineup the rest of the year (unless they go to the DL). So I had to weigh immediate help from Pedroia or potential stretch run help from Kinsler. I still took Pedroia.