Luck/Hyde/Kelce+ vs. Cam/Ware/Reed+ (1 Viewer)

[East Bay Rounder]

Standard scoring, 12 Team, PPR League

My team is in development mode... and downgrading and picking up extra pieces is ideal... received this trade offer:

I give:  Luck, Hyde, Kelce, Baldwin, 2018 3rd

I get:  Cam, Ware/West, Reed, Pryor, 2018 1st and 2nd

I think giving up Baldwin is a bit too much for this trade and countered with giving up either Boyd, Lee, or Sharpe.

Thoughts about the initial offer and my counter offers?

 

[jwsbowler]

I don't like any part of the deal.  what's wrong with developing with the 4 you have???  The value loss of Kelce to Reed alone (too many injuries for my liking) does not make up the pick upgrades that you would receive let alone the value loss of the other players involved.  

 

[Warhogs]

The only part you win on is the picks.  I hate the deal.

 

[aaj1997]

I agree - do not like this deal for you at all.  Better ways to accumulate 2018 draft picks.

 

[smbkrypt24]

Keep what you have. I'm curious why do you want to make this trade? It seems a downgrade at each position 

 

[FredG]

Agree - not a good trade - Baldwin is solid and reliable, Luck is good and even better if Colts do something with their offense line to keep him on his feet. Kelce has just shown what he can do and I was not so high on Hyde before until I saw comments on his tape plus the impact of Shanahan. Shanahan could do for him what he has done for others in his past assignments.

Ware flashed great but look as the second half of last season - not sure he holds up on his production. Reed is tops when he is on the field but he is off a lot and you have Kelce who is probably a better long term option. Pryor could do well but you would be betting on him adapting successfully to the new system. And Cam vs Luck? I'd take Luck any day.

Seems like you are losing ground other than the picks and everyone hopes they can land the next Zeke but if you look at the history of high round picks these don't work more often than they do.

I would pass if I were you.