M.Gordon for J.Charles (1 Viewer)

[Chief]

Rules:

10 yd = 1 pt

TD run/rec = 10 pt

TD pass = 5 pt

Should I pull the trigger on this trade offered to me:  CHARLES and JACKSON for GORDON and HOGAN.

I have been holding onto Charles all this time and haven't played him yet.  I think that is what is holding me back.  Was considering dropping Jackson for Meredith or Sproles for depth anyhow.  Help!  TIA.

My roster:


T Brady
B Roethlisberger (R)


J Charles
D Murray
D Henry (R)


M Thomas
A Cooper
T Pryor (R)
D Moncrief (R)
D Jackson (R)


R Gronkowski
K Rudolph (R)


J Tucker


Eagles

 

[mrpuck2799]

I am not a big fan of Gordon with his YPC, but he has no competition.  

Charles has boom/bust all over him, nobody knows how he will come back from the injury but chances are slowly.

Ware will probably be a 50/50 split for awhile too, more under-valuing him.  

I'd probably make the trade.  

 

[themeistersinger]

If Charles is completely healthy he could be a top 5 RB.  No way to know that of course, so you'e gambling either way.  Gordon has been extremely TD dependent, but he has a lock on the starting job on a much better offense, and the SD line is getting healthier.  After the 2 matchups with Denver his schedule looks pretty good too.

Still, the upside for Gordon is nowhere near the upside for Charles.  I'd be inclined to take the Charles side of that trade.  D Jax and Hogan are a wash to me, so it doesn't sway me either way.

 

[themeistersinger]

If I were you I'd be shopping either Brady or Roethlisberger - you should be able to get a decent return from either of those 2.  

 

[need2know]

If I were you I'd be shopping either Brady or Roethlisberger - you should be able to get a decent return from either of those 2.  

This.  Get rid of one of these studs for something to help your team

 

[walbridge20]

I agree with trying to move a QB. All in all I like Gordon a little more than Charles right now but all it takes is one good game from JC to remind us all that he is a stud. Gordon isn't there yet-he's just the only show in town