maclin or bryant (1 Viewer)

[whitewizard]

they tend to get drafted about the same time with the biggest denominator of who goes first relying on who in your league love that respective team.

so i ask you who will actually be better. i am partial to maclin a deep threat on an offense based on the notion it is 50 yards or nothing.

bryant can develop into that sparkling #2 guy who could be a number one on most teams.

the downsides will maclin get the ball enough, can bryant step into the sun?

i don't know any ideas would be great.

 

[T with T]

Bryant and it's not even that close. Bryant a number 2 guy haa, no way bud Bryant will be WR1 on the cowboys by 2012 if not this year.. Miles austin will fit a good 1 B, or 2nd slot

 

[The Doctor]

bryant has more potential this year. hes supposedly looking amazing and if i had the option id go with him. there are starting to be too many options on the eagles to pass to.

please see mine

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=603936

 

[Banger]

with Maclin's mysterious injury that they're all hush hush on, it's Bryant easily. Even if he were fully healthy I'd still do with Bryant. I think he has the talent to park in or around the top 5 for years he just has to keep his head on straight....Maclin IMO doesn't have the kind of upside.

 

[JoeSteeler]

DezRotoworld;

Jeremy Maclin (undisclosed) has returned to his hometown of St. Louis for further testing.It's time to get concerned. Maclin hasn't practiced yet, appears noticeably thin and is now leaving the team. He's going back to St. Louis to try to identify the mysterious illness that has apparently bothered him since last spring. At this point, Maclin is no lock to be ready for Week 1. Owners drafting early need to tread lightly until more details are revealed.

 

[steelcityman]

I got Dez, and expect big things this year, some not so great games, but some huge games which he can wins me the week. As my WR2, I am fine with that.

 

[Phlash]

with Maclin's mysterious injury that they're all hush hush on, it's Bryant easily. Even if he were fully healthy I'd still do with Bryant. I think he has the talent to park in or around the top 5 for years he just has to keep his head on straight....Maclin IMO doesn't have the kind of upside.

Going to have to disagree with you on that one. Maclin and Dez Bryant are both athletic freaks. They both have crazy upside. Implying that Maclin doesn't have "the kind of upside" that Dez does is a huge disservice to his level of skill and talent. He easily could be a 90/1400/14 kind of guy.

 

[rizzler]

with Maclin's mysterious injury that they're all hush hush on, it's Bryant easily. Even if he were fully healthy I'd still do with Bryant. I think he has the talent to park in or around the top 5 for years he just has to keep his head on straight....Maclin IMO doesn't have the kind of upside.

Going to have to disagree with you on that one. Maclin and Dez Bryant are both athletic freaks. They both have crazy upside. Implying that Maclin doesn't have "the kind of upside" that Dez does is a huge disservice to his level of skill and talent. He easily could be a 90/1400/14 kind of guy.

While I agree Maclin is a freak (which this term get abused, even by me)... Dez is a super-freak, super-freak... he's super-freakay!!!

 

[T with T]

Let's just hope Maclin is Ok, this news about his situation is disturbing and hopefully he checks out ok and recovers... I like both guys though alot.

 

[fightingillini]

While I think Maclin is a solid WR, I would take Dez all day. Higher upside IMO.

 

[Touchdown Syndrome]

Dez, without hesitation.

I'm a fan of Maclin, but Dez has the upside to be a top 5 WR in the league.