Manning or Addai at 7? (1 Viewer)

[moneys]

I pick seven in a 12 team league with 6pts for any td 1pts. for every 10 rush yd's and 1pt. for every 20 pass yd's.

Figure I will not need another qb. to pick until my last round if I take Manning.

IF both Manning and Addai are still there at 7 who should I pick and why?

 

[Colin Dowling]

Run your numbers in the VBD Excel sheet....Addai by a wide margin between the two.

 

[moneys]

Run your numbers in the VBD Excel sheet....Addai by a wide margin between the two.

don't mean to ask a stupid ? but what is a vbd excel sheet?

 

[Redwes25]

make your own decisions - it is more fun that way.

 

[Sammy B]

Run your numbers in the VBD Excel sheet....Addai by a wide margin between the two.

don't mean to ask a stupid ? but what is a vbd excel sheet?

 

[Deuce'sWild]

Had the same decision....I took Manning. Followed with Henry in the 2nd rd, Portis in the 3rd rd, Gates in the 4th rd (STEAL), and got A. Green and Betts later in the draft.

You can get RB talent later this year due to the depth at RB. Where you suffer is at WR, I didn't get one until Rd 5 (Walker), and the R. Moss in Rd 6, and Berrian in 7th I think. Then A. Green and Betts.

I could be off on the Rounds, but those are some of the guys I ended up with.

GL.

 

[Colin Dowling]

Run your numbers in the VBD Excel sheet....Addai by a wide margin between the two.

don't mean to ask a stupid ? but what is a vbd excel sheet?

A "lifechanging" event, located on the FBG home page....

 

[shadyridr]

Had the same decision....I took Manning. Followed with Henry in the 2nd rd, Portis in the 3rd rd, Gates in the 4th rd (STEAL), and got A. Green and Betts later in the draft.You can get RB talent later this year due to the depth at RB. Where you suffer is at WR, I didn't get one until Rd 5 (Walker), and the R. Moss in Rd 6, and Berrian in 7th I think. Then A. Green and Betts.I could be off on the Rounds, but those are some of the guys I ended up with.GL.

So you basically got everybody a round after their ADPs? Who did you draft with children? Kind of joking but I dont think many people can expect drafts like that.

 

[TheFanatic]

I go with Addai, but then again I have Addai as third on my board behind LT and SJax...

 

[The Shizzle]

Does VBD take the fun out of making your own decisions?

 

[mdog1967]

Had the same decision....I took Manning. Followed with Henry in the 2nd rd, Portis in the 3rd rd, Gates in the 4th rd (STEAL), and got A. Green and Betts later in the draft.You can get RB talent later this year due to the depth at RB. Where you suffer is at WR, I didn't get one until Rd 5 (Walker), and the R. Moss in Rd 6, and Berrian in 7th I think. Then A. Green and Betts.I could be off on the Rounds, but those are some of the guys I ended up with.GL.

Actually a very Solid Draft, I think A. Green and especially Betts make taking Portis a decent Risk.

 

[DodgerDen]

I'd go with Addai.

 

[Keepers]

Had the same decision....I took Manning. Followed with Henry in the 2nd rd, Portis in the 3rd rd, Gates in the 4th rd (STEAL), and got A. Green and Betts later in the draft.You can get RB talent later this year due to the depth at RB. Where you suffer is at WR, I didn't get one until Rd 5 (Walker), and the R. Moss in Rd 6, and Berrian in 7th I think. Then A. Green and Betts.I could be off on the Rounds, but those are some of the guys I ended up with.GL.

Good draft.In a league the has 6 pts for all TDs and 1 pt for 20 yards passing, Manning is very tempting.

 

[cjack]

I'd go with Addai.

Don't, you'll experience buyer's remorse.

 

[Deuce'sWild]

Had the same decision....I took Manning. Followed with Henry in the 2nd rd, Portis in the 3rd rd, Gates in the 4th rd (STEAL), and got A. Green and Betts later in the draft.You can get RB talent later this year due to the depth at RB. Where you suffer is at WR, I didn't get one until Rd 5 (Walker), and the R. Moss in Rd 6, and Berrian in 7th I think. Then A. Green and Betts.I could be off on the Rounds, but those are some of the guys I ended up with.GL.

So you basically got everybody a round after their ADPs? Who did you draft with children? Kind of joking but I dont think many people can expect drafts like that.

I think what happened was a QB run in the late 3rd-early 4th Rd, which allowed me to get Gates, and then that started a TE run in the late 4th which allowed me to get Walker in the 5th. So, basically I dictated the draft. Doesn't happen to often but I got lucky this time around.