Marshawn Lynch vs. Fred Jackson (1 Viewer)

[jimmyd9989]

I have FJax but got offered a trade in my 16 team league. I am skeptical on both..... can some one tell me what they think?

 

[Resident A]

They both have low-end RB2 upside, and bench fodder downside. I'd say they're equal FF-wise, though I wouldn't be comfortable with either as any more than a RB4.

 

[jimmyd9989]

They both have low-end RB2 upside, and bench fodder downside. I'd say they're equal FF-wise, though I wouldn't be comfortable with either as any more than a RB4.

My only concern would be who would see more of the carries? Fred Jackson against a 9th pick rookie or Lynch against an established back with limited upside? Basically my question would be who would be more likely to have more carries going forward?