Mixon or R. White? (1 Viewer)

[Leroy Hoard]

Redraft, standard scoring.

These two are pretty close in the rankings, just wanted any opinions who you would rather have this season.

TIA

 

[Big Nate]

Mixon. Better offense and likely more scoring opportunities which is important in std scoring. White's pass catching chops don't really make a difference in std scoring so I lean Mixon.

For me it isn't close. I think Mixon can score more TDs than White this year.

In my one std scoring league last year Mixon outscored White and White had 30 more touches. White just isn't that efficient and if he loses touches this year it could be bad.

 

[Jaruby]

logically speaking it’s White, he has the upside from last years chemistry with Baker and passing upside but I prefer Mixon, he’s just a better RB.

 

[Gally]

Mixon fairly easy for me. I don't think White is that good and was good in fantasy last year due to volume alone. I think that volume gets cut significantly by Bucky Irving this year and he falls because of it.

 

[Big Nate]

logically speaking it’s White, he has the upside from last years chemistry with Baker and passing upside but I prefer Mixon, he’s just a better RB.

I don't see it that way, but maybe I'm missing something. When I saw how inefficient he was rushing the ball and was surviving off volume alone it concerned me. As a result I traded him away later year in a deep keeper league while his value was high.

If he doesn't get the volume again it could be a struggle for him to produce fantasy points, especially since this is standard scoring (no-ppr). Passing upside doesn't matter very much in std.

 

[Jaruby]

logically speaking it’s White, he has the upside from last years chemistry with Baker and passing upside but I prefer Mixon, he’s just a better RB.

I don't see it that way, but maybe I'm missing something. When I saw how inefficient he was rushing the ball and was surviving off volume alone it concerned me. As a result I traded him away later year in a deep keeper league while his value was high.

If he doesn't get the volume again it could be a struggle for him to produce fantasy points, especially since this is standard scoring (no-ppr). Passing upside doesn't matter very much in std.

I think Mixon will get plenty of volume and most of the goal line work so I’m not sure what you mean. He’s just a better back than White. I’d draft him.

 

[Big Nate]

logically speaking it’s White, he has the upside from last years chemistry with Baker and passing upside but I prefer Mixon, he’s just a better RB.

I don't see it that way, but maybe I'm missing something. When I saw how inefficient he was rushing the ball and was surviving off volume alone it concerned me. As a result I traded him away later year in a deep keeper league while his value was high.

If he doesn't get the volume again it could be a struggle for him to produce fantasy points, especially since this is standard scoring (no-ppr). Passing upside doesn't matter very much in std.

I think Mixon will get plenty of volume and most of the goal line work so I’m not sure what you mean. He’s just a better back than White. I’d draft him.

Sorry I think it was just your initial line of "logically it is white". I'm in on Mixon this year.

 

[Ramerica]

I think Mixon and it's not close, especially in a standard league. Better offense with more chances to score and he also doesn't have rookie Bucky Irving on his tail.