Most Over Hyped/Rated (1 Viewer)

[Hemi-Colon]

Havent seen this in a while and thought it might be time. Curious about thoughts on who just hasnt or cannot earn the hype. Not neccesarily players who let theyre respective teams or your fantasy team down, but players who have been said to be "sure things" that never had a chance. As a Niner homer, I will throw Vernon Davis onto the fire first. The guy is without question one of the most athletic players in the game, but how did all the experts miss the fact that he has stone hands and a 10 cent head. Good Luck to those playing today.

 

[FreeBaGeL]

Jamarcus Russell will never be a successful NFL QB. Even in college when he was playing alongside a bunch of NFL 1st rounders he cost his team countless games with dumb turnovers.

He has a strong arm and that is absolutely it. No touch, no accuracy, and no brains.

 

[BILLY_THE_BULL]

Peyton Manning, he is no Tom Brady

 

[beef]

the steelers and cowboys

 

[The Man with the Plan]

Elisha Manning

Reggie Bush

Vince Young

Matt Leinart

 

[beef]

Elisha ManningReggie BushVince YoungMatt Leinart

solid list

 

[baconstripdivots]

Elisha ManningReggie BushVince YoungMatt Leinart

solid list

Wow. Couldn't agree more. I'm a Giants fan, and I have to admit that E. Manning deserves top billing on this list. I've come to the realization that he will never lead his team to a Championship. Reggie Bush a real close second. Mario Williams not looking so bad with the #1 pick last year.

 

[Ryan_21]

Jamarcus Russell will never be a successful NFL QB. Even in college when he was playing alongside a bunch of NFL 1st rounders he cost his team countless games with dumb turnovers.He has a strong arm and that is absolutely it. No touch, no accuracy, and no brains.

Pretty rediculous to make this claim after only 2 games.

 

[Bojang0301]

Jamarcus Russell will never be a successful NFL QB. Even in college when he was playing alongside a bunch of NFL 1st rounders he cost his team countless games with dumb turnovers.He has a strong arm and that is absolutely it. No touch, no accuracy, and no brains.

Pretty rediculous to make this claim after only 2 games.

I believe he was making it after his college career.

 

[FreeBaGeL]

Jamarcus Russell will never be a successful NFL QB. Even in college when he was playing alongside a bunch of NFL 1st rounders he cost his team countless games with dumb turnovers.He has a strong arm and that is absolutely it. No touch, no accuracy, and no brains.

Pretty rediculous to make this claim after only 2 games.

I believe he was making it after his college career.

Indeed. I would never make this assumption based on what I saw of a rookie in his first game, especially a quarterback playing against a tough and aggressive Jags defense. Most QB's stink in their first game, but this is the same stuff I was saying about Russell heading into the draft.

 

[Popinski]

Elisha ManningReggie BushVince YoungMatt Leinart

solid list

I'm a Giants fan, and I have to admit that E. Manning deserves top billing on this list. I've come to the realization that he will never lead his team to a Championship.

The most Eli will ever lead his team to once in a while is a regular season win. Any postseason success his team has will likely be despite his play.

 

[Young 8]

"The Bust Legacy"

Ryan Leaf ---> Tim Couch ---> David Carr ---> Alex Smith