My ARob for his Baldwin and West WHIR (1 Viewer)

[jarridk]

Would you trade Allen Robinson for Doug Baldwin and Terrance West in non-ppr?

My rbs are Gurley, Gordon, Ware and Dixon (start 3)

My wrs are Evans, Robinson, Snead and Coates

Thanks.

 

[HokieInMD]

Ravens fan here. West is getting the carries, but he's not taking over games. The coaching staff will still seek ways to get Dixon involved (my opinion).

I think SEA offense will get better as Wilson heals, so Baldwin stock should rise. I would go ahead and pull the trigger.

 

[jarridk]

Thanks for response.  do you think west keeps job and keeps putting up high-end rb2 low-end rb1 numbers or do you think dixon gets shot this year?  i would probably not make trade if you told me in 2 weeks that dixon-west in 50/50 timeshare.  trading down from arob to baldwin b/c i think west surprises and becomes solid rb2 with upside ros

 

[HokieInMD]

Dixon still doesn't look right. New OC didn't look like a different gameplan last week - Flacco threw too much (IMO). 

Bortles is stuck - I heard on FBG podcast that he didn't put in the work this past offseason that he did before last season and it's showing on the field. 

I think locking up the BAL backfield is worth the downgrade from ARob to Baldwin - again, Baldwin #s should improve as Russell Wilson's health does. 

You'll have 4 of the 32 starting RBs on your team - that should be a distinct advantage in a 10- or 12-tm league.

 

[TX Steel]

I agree that although I'm not high on West, the combo of him and Baldwin is worth the downgrade from ARob.  West is still getting carries even though Dixon is back, and ARob is struggling with Bortles regressing.  It wouldn't shock me if Baldwin matched ARob's production ROS, with the way their arrows are currently pointing.

Good luck, and please see mine if you have a minute:  https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749837-offered-bennett-for-my-crabtree-whir/

 

[Gally]

Is Baldwin really a downgrade from Robinson this year?  I believe Baldwin is outperforming Robinson thus far on the season.  I assume this is a re-draft and if that is the case this is an easy trade to accept.  You are basically getting a wash (or little improvement) at WR and a free RB. 

 

[beantown76]

Definitely Yes. You should pull the trigger on this deal. 

Help with mine?

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749886-meredith-for-fitz-whir/

 

[jarridk]

bump