My top 10 wr's (1 Viewer)

[Blackjacks]

1. Marshall (2)

2. Owens (1)

3. Fitz (same)

4. S. Smith (6)

5. Wayne (4)

6. Jennings (9)

7. Calvin Johnson (8)

8. Boldin (5)

9. Burress (10)

10. Cotchery (out of top ten)

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

 

[mmarsian]

I think you've got Calvin Johnson a bit too high, and Boldin too low. Granted Boldin got his bell rung this past weekend, but if he can keep playing, I'd prefer Boldin 10x to Calvin.

Oh, and I think I'd put Dwayne Bowe in Cotchery's place!

 

[AnonymousBob]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

 

[49erBamBam52]

1. Marshall (2)2. Owens (1)3. Fitz (same)4. S. Smith (6)5. Wayne (4)6. Jennings (9)7. Calvin Johnson (8)8. Boldin (5)9. Burress (10)10. Cotchery (out of top ten)I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

What about Santana Moss... no love?he has the same amount of TD's as cotchery, but twice the yards...just a thought, as i have both of them on my team and id start Santana over Jericho anyday.That combined with Jets being on a bye this week. BAM

 

[Sweet Love]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He is #2 in my PPR too...he is the Philip Rivers of WRs...it is going to take a lot more games for people to believe in him...there is no "selling high" at this point.

 

[HellToupee]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

 

[travdogg]

1. Marshall (2)2. Owens (1)3. Fitz (same)4. S. Smith (6)5. Wayne (4)6. Jennings (9)7. Calvin Johnson (8)8. Boldin (5)9. Burress (10)10. Cotchery (out of top ten)I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Good to see AJ out of the top-10. I still think Cotchery may not be worthy quite yet as I'm not entirely sure he's even the #1 WR on the Jets. I'd rank them:1. Marshall, he's on another level right now.2. Wayne, I really think he's gonna be money with Manning getting healthier.3. Owens, his penchant for randomly disappearing keeps him below Wayne.4. Smith, people got Marshall and Smith a round lower due to their suspensions look smart.5. Fitz, I worry about Warner getting benched or hurt at some point. 6. Santana, he's back and he's likely going to stick around all year.7. Calvin, possible QB change is only major issue.8. Burress, see TO minus 1 game.9. Boldin, how will injury hurt him?10. Jennings, doesn't look like a one year wonder.Honorable mention: Bowe, White, Cotchery and AJ.

 

[Blackjacks]

I think you've got Calvin Johnson a bit too high, and Boldin too low. Granted Boldin got his bell rung this past weekend, but if he can keep playing, I'd prefer Boldin 10x to Calvin.Oh, and I think I'd put Dwayne Bowe in Cotchery's place!

Boldin is one of my favorite players and I moved him down a little due to the injury. If he comes back and looks good he'll move right back up. Calvin has looked very good in 2 out of 3 games. If anything I think he'll play better than this ranking towards the end of the year.Bowe has looked good but the qb spot just scares me too much to put him in my top ten

 

[Blackjacks]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

 

[49erBamBam52]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

 

[two_dollars]

Hey where's Randy?

 

[AnonymousBob]

Hey where's Randy?

Outside the top ten. As he should be.

 

[Blackjacks]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

 

[49erBamBam52]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

wait... so is this list of WR's top 10 based on previous years results, or this years production so far?im calm, sorry if my last post came off a bit brash, it was not intended.

i like the post... enjoy reading your others, and think this is a good list you have put together...

its nothing personal, i just think Moss is top 10 instead of cotchery...

CHEERS!!

BAM

 

[supermark_28]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

Blackjacks,I agree it's only 4 games but my concern is that Moss continues to blow up and he'll be unattainable at some point.

After Philly,Washington takes on: St Louis,Cleveland and Detroit,some real nice matchups.

 

[zoonation]

Cotchery is fool's gold.

 

[brednbuddah]

Jennings should be a couple slots higher. nine more yards in week 1 and he'd have 4 100+ yard games to start the season.

S.Moss needs to be on the list.

 

[cubbie5150]

Cotchery is fool's gold.

I feel the same...and I own him. Trying to deal him the past 2 weeks, no one seems to want him in my league

 

[bumpman]

Cotchery is fool's gold.

I feel the same...and I own him. Trying to deal him the past 2 weeks, no one seems to want him in my league

That's funny. That's exactly how I feel about S. Moss. He is having a great start, but injuries and inconsistency will likely rear its ugly head again.

 

[Blackjacks]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

wait... so is this list of WR's top 10 based on previous years results, or this years production so far?im calm, sorry if my last post came off a bit brash, it was not intended.

i like the post... enjoy reading your others, and think this is a good list you have put together...

its nothing personal, i just think Moss is top 10 instead of cotchery...

CHEERS!!

BAM

It's where I would draft guys if drafting today and I still wouldn't trust Santana Moss in my top ten. I know he has started off hot but I'm not buying it. I've had him before and got fooled and I believe he'll let owners down again. Washington is a run first team now and will be in another 3 weeks. Moss has been getting some td's right now but as the year goes on I think those td's will get filtered out to the likes of Cooley, more to Portis, and the two rookie wr's. Plus Campbell has looked good the last 3 games which I'm not sold on him yet either. If the 10th spot would be out for grabs between Cotchery and Moss and both of them deserved it I would look at qb and Cotchery would definitely keep his ranking.

 

[Banger]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

wait... so is this list of WR's top 10 based on previous years results, or this years production so far?im calm, sorry if my last post came off a bit brash, it was not intended.

i like the post... enjoy reading your others, and think this is a good list you have put together...

its nothing personal, i just think Moss is top 10 instead of cotchery...

CHEERS!!

BAM

It's where I would draft guys if drafting today and I still wouldn't trust Santana Moss in my top ten. I know he has started off hot but I'm not buying it. I've had him before and got fooled and I believe he'll let owners down again. Washington is a run first team now and will be in another 3 weeks. Moss has been getting some td's right now but as the year goes on I think those td's will get filtered out to the likes of Cooley, more to Portis, and the two rookie wr's. Plus Campbell has looked good the last 3 games which I'm not sold on him yet either. If the 10th spot would be out for grabs between Cotchery and Moss and both of them deserved it I would look at qb and Cotchery would definitely keep his ranking.

I agree about Moss in general that he has shown flashes in the past and hasn't been consistent year to year (I've never been a big fan) but there has been a coaching and coordinator change so you have to account for that. Yes Wash has been a running team with Saunders but he's gone and now they have zorn who was a qb and believe has a passing philosophy so its possible that while the key players remain the same that the distribution will change based on the new philosophy. It looks that way after 4 games at least....

 

[Blackjacks]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

wait... so is this list of WR's top 10 based on previous years results, or this years production so far?im calm, sorry if my last post came off a bit brash, it was not intended.

i like the post... enjoy reading your others, and think this is a good list you have put together...

its nothing personal, i just think Moss is top 10 instead of cotchery...

CHEERS!!

BAM

It's where I would draft guys if drafting today and I still wouldn't trust Santana Moss in my top ten. I know he has started off hot but I'm not buying it. I've had him before and got fooled and I believe he'll let owners down again. Washington is a run first team now and will be in another 3 weeks. Moss has been getting some td's right now but as the year goes on I think those td's will get filtered out to the likes of Cooley, more to Portis, and the two rookie wr's. Plus Campbell has looked good the last 3 games which I'm not sold on him yet either. If the 10th spot would be out for grabs between Cotchery and Moss and both of them deserved it I would look at qb and Cotchery would definitely keep his ranking.

I agree about Moss in general that he has shown flashes in the past and hasn't been consistent year to year (I've never been a big fan) but there has been a coaching and coordinator change so you have to account for that. Yes Wash has been a running team with Saunders but he's gone and now they have zorn who was a qb and believe has a passing philosophy so its possible that while the key players remain the same that the distribution will change based on the new philosophy. It looks that way after 4 games at least....

I can atleast see where you are coming from.Good post!!!!

I'm gonna give it a couple of weeks

 

[49erBamBam52]

Not a bad list. I'm curious to see where you would rank Santana Moss...he's the #2 wr in my league and you don't have him ranked in your top ten.

He's #2 in my league also...there is no FREAKING way I would take him in my top ten though.I don't like his inconsistency.

I will say he has started off the year very good but I;m not ready to buy yet on him

WHA??Cotchery's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 NYJ 3 80 1 14

2 NYJ 1 20 2

3 NYJ 10 76 0 7.6

4 NYJ 4 67 2 18.7

Moss's production bold is fantasy standard scoring non PPR

Week Rec Yd TD Pts

1 WAS 5 37 1 9.7

2 WAS 7 164 1 26.1

3 WAS 7 75 1 13.5

4 WAS 8 145 0 14.5

Which part is more consistant again??

im confused!?!?

i could understand in not having faith in his future production, but id say the consistancy here lies with Moss...

BAM

It's only 4 games, calm it down

wait... so is this list of WR's top 10 based on previous years results, or this years production so far?im calm, sorry if my last post came off a bit brash, it was not intended.

i like the post... enjoy reading your others, and think this is a good list you have put together...

its nothing personal, i just think Moss is top 10 instead of cotchery...

CHEERS!!

BAM

It's where I would draft guys if drafting today and I still wouldn't trust Santana Moss in my top ten. I know he has started off hot but I'm not buying it. I've had him before and got fooled and I believe he'll let owners down again. Washington is a run first team now and will be in another 3 weeks. Moss has been getting some td's right now but as the year goes on I think those td's will get filtered out to the likes of Cooley, more to Portis, and the two rookie wr's. Plus Campbell has looked good the last 3 games which I'm not sold on him yet either. If the 10th spot would be out for grabs between Cotchery and Moss and both of them deserved it I would look at qb and Cotchery would definitely keep his ranking.

OK, guess thats where i got confused... i took this as more of a "who shouold you start" kind of thread, as opposed to a "who i would draft" type thread.you make a very good point in that they are very similar when it comes to potential production, and QB makes the difference, ill give you that one for sure Favre>Cambell.

I own both of them in one of my leagues, and as far as who i would start with confidence this week and the next and so on, considering how each has played, i still go with Moss... at least until either Moss lets me down, or Cotchery steps it up...

But so far niether of those has happened and cotchery might make my starting roster depending on matchups, whereas Moss will remain in my starting lineup.

Thanks for clearing the air

BAM

 

[Blackjacks]

Jennings should be a couple slots higher. nine more yards in week 1 and he'd have 4 100+ yard games to start the season.



S.Moss needs to be on the list.

how do you feel about that statement now?

 

[Blackjacks]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

yes

 

[MCguidance]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

yes

AJ in for next week?Moss still out.

BMarshall takes a bit of a hit.

Fitz up a bit.

 

[Shlon]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

yes

AJ in for next week?Moss still out.

BMarshall takes a bit of a hit.

Fitz up a bit.

What about Roddy White?

 

[Blackjacks]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

yes

AJ in for next week? very closeMoss still out. never has been in and not changing now

BMarshall takes a bit of a hit. maybe a little but he's still a stud

Fitz up a bit. he good

 

[cubbie5150]

Brandon Marshall's performance in week 5 proves the point that ANY WR can be shutdown if the def coordinator wants to do so; I agree that Roddy White deserves consideration, just wish he would've done just a little something in the 2nd half today.

 

[Blackjacks]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

yes

AJ in for next week?Moss still out.

BMarshall takes a bit of a hit.

Fitz up a bit.

What about Roddy White? probably not but he is a nice young player

 

[towney]

AJ now needs some consideration.

 

[Shlon]

I'm kicking Andre Johnson out of the top ten until he has a good game

Still waiting on Santana Moss to show you something? for posting you list anyhoo

yes

AJ in for next week?Moss still out.

BMarshall takes a bit of a hit.

Fitz up a bit.

What about Roddy White? probably not but he is a nice young player

3rd in the league right now in receiving yards with a rookie QB and no other WR to take heat off him. Falcons really need another WR to compliment White.

 

[Burning Sensation]

AJ now needs some consideration.

Some? he should never have been out of the top 10.

 

[Skilo]

AJ now needs some consideration.

Some? he should never have been out of the top 10.

I feel he most certainly should be out of the top 10 this year. He and his team has played poorly up till last week. If he has another week somewhat like this past week, then he should be back in the top 10. Until he shows just a little bit of consistency, I wouldn't have him in my top 10 (and Im a Houston homer).

 

[timoleander]

I would like to believe the Calvin Johnson ranking, but, with Kitna likely no longer at the helm (not that he was doing much anyway), I just can't see him performing like the others in the list.

 

[FantasyFantasyFootball]

I think you've got Calvin Johnson a bit too high, and Boldin too low. Granted Boldin got his bell rung this past weekend, but if he can keep playing, I'd prefer Boldin 10x to Calvin.Oh, and I think I'd put Dwayne Bowe in Cotchery's place!

Coles will outperform Cotchery this year. If you ignore the first week when Coles had a thigh injury, he's done better.