nerangers
Footballguy
FINAL!
Includes a Viking/Ram trade
Think the Saints/Jet trade and get the players I have them listed with
1 1 Houston - Mario Williams, DE (changed Reggie Bush, RB) - though they should take Williams all along
2 2 New Orleans - D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT (changed Mario Williams) - best player now for the Saints
3 3 Tennessee - Vince Young, QB
4 4 N.Y. Jets - Reggie Bush, RB (changed D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT) - best chance of getting Bush now
5 5 Green Bay - A.J. Hawk, LB
6 6 San Francisco - Vernon Davis, TE
7 7 Oakland - Matt Leinart, QB
8 8 Buffalo - Winston Justice, OT
9 9 Detroit - Michael Huff, S
10 10 Arizona - Ernie Sims, LB (changed Haloti Ngata, DT) - Moving up the board
11 11 (TRADE) Vikings – Jay Cutler, QB
12 12 Cleveland - Haloti Ngata, DT (changed Kamerion Wimbley, DE) - favored over Wimbley
13 13 Baltimore - Brodrick Bunkley, DT
14 14 Philadelphia - Chad Jackson, WR
15 15 Denver - Santonio Holmes, WR
16 16 Miami - Antonio Cromartie, CB (changed Manny Lawson, DE/OLB) - read Miami really wants him
17 17 (TRADE) St. Louis - Jimmy Williams, DB
18 18 Dallas - Manny Lawson, DE/OLB (changed Ernie Sims, LB) - better fit for Dallas anyway
19 19 San Diego - Tye Hill, CB
20 20 Kansas City - Jonathan Joseph, CB (changed Antonio Cromartie, CB) - still need the position
21 21 New England - DeAngelo Williams, RB
22 22 San Francisco - Kamerion Wimbley, DE (changed Mathius Kiwanuka, DE) - Better DE for their system
23 23 Tampa Bay - Mathius Kiwanuka, DE (changed Jonathan Joseph, CB) - fills a need
24 24 Cincinnati - Donte Whitner, S
25 25 N.Y. Giants - Sinorice Moss, WR (changed Bobby Carpenter, LB) - Giants now have Arrington, and does not need Carpenter
26 26 Chicago - S/CB Jason Allen (changed Sinorice Moss, WR) - think the Bears will trade out of this pick altogether
27 27 Carolina - Chad Greenway, LB
28 28 Jacksonville – Thomas Howard, OLB/S
29 29 N.Y. Jets - Bobby Carpenter, LB (changed Demeco Ryans, LB) - Same position, different player
30 30 Indianapolis - Laurence Maroney, RB
31 31 Seattle – Kelley Jennings, CB
32 32 Pittsburgh – LenDale White, RB
______________________________________________________
I thought it would be fun to enter one of the rookie mock drafts online...so here is my rookie attempt at my first rookie mock draft ever!
Mind you, I am not an expert on rookies by any stretch of the imagination. I am posting it here so the experts can show me the error of my ways with picks for there home teams. I looked online at a site that listed the top three weaknesses on each team and made picks based on that.
Here goes:
1 1 Houston - Reggie Bush, RB: Definitely the #1 draft pick of the draft,, but wonder if the Texans really need him and DD? I think the Texans would do better with DE Mario Williams or trade out of this pick. (Alternate pick: Mario Williams, DE)
2 2 New Orleans - Mario Williams, DE: This pick could easily be D'brickashaw Ferguson, but from what I read online, it seems the Saints have Williams and Hawk higher on their draft board. The Saints could move down a few spots and get one of them (trade with Titans or Jets) or you just make the pick right here. With Brees in the fold, I don’t see them going for a QB. (Alternate pick: D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT, A.J. Hawk, LB)
3 3 Tennessee - Vince Young, QB: A lot going on with Tennessee and McNair. I think Volek will start, and groom the next QB. General Manager Floyd Reese likes Vince Young, so that is the pick. If they are not going to pick Leinart, they probably could trade down on this pick to get Young. If Tennessee did pick Leinart, I don’t see the Jets taking Vince Young. (Alternate pick: D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT, Matt Leinart, QB)
4 4 N.Y. Jets - Matt Leinart, QB: I know they now have Pennington and Ramsey, but how to you pass on Leinart especially if you do not have to trade up to get him? (Alternate Pick: D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT, Mario Williams, DE)
5 5 Green Bay - A.J. Hawk, LB: From everything I read, this pick just makes sense. Since I have D'brickashaw Ferguson falling, maybe GB would pick him, but it seems that GB would have to do a lot of shuffling to use him.
6 6 San Francisco - Michael Huff, S: OK, I know everyone else has Vernon Davis here, and it does make sense to give Alex Smith another target to throw at. There are a few other TEs in the draft though, and adding Huff adds to a secondary that lacks both depth and talent. If GB does not take Hawk, he is also another option here. (Alternate pick: Mario Williams, DE, Vernon Davis, TE, A.J. Hawk, LB, D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT)
7 7 Oakland - Vernon Davis, TE: SF loss, Oakland’s gain. Had the Jets not taken Leinart, Oakland would have (don’t read so much into the Aaron Brooks signing, the need is still there). I read if they could not get Leinart or Young here, and Vernon Davis was around, he could be the pick. (Alternate Picks: Matt Leinart, QB, Vince Young, QB, Michael Huff, S)
8 8 Buffalo - D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT: Someone always slips in the draft, and I know Ferguson is the most unlikely, but it is how my draft panned out. Someone might trade up to get him, but I didn’t do any trades in my draft. The Saints, Jets, or GB could easily draft him. He won’t get past Buffalo though. If Ferguson is not the one to side, I think they would still draft position and take Justice. (Alternate: Winston Justice, OT)
9 9 Detroit - Winston Justice, OT: Detroit has a terrible offensive line that could make Justice a starter. (Alternate: Michael Huff, S)
10 10 Arizona - Haloti Ngata, DT: Most Arizona fans don’t think the Cardinals would take Cutler here, so adding a tackle seemed to make sense. Cutler is one of those players that could slide in the draft the same way Rogers did last year. Could the Vikings try to trade up here thinking Arizona will grab Cutler? (Alternate: Jay Cutler, QB)
11 11 St. Louis - Jimmy Williams, DB: I was actually thinking Sims here, but went with Williams. I read that the Rams have quantity vs quality at this position, so Williams should be an upgrade. (Alternate: Ernie Sims, LB, Tye Hill, CB)
12 12 Cleveland - Kamerion Wimbley, DE: Cleveland was looking at Ngata and Wimbley and Wimbley is still here. This pick could also end up being Bunkley in place of Wimbley (Alternate: Brodrick Bunkley, DT)
13 13 Baltimore - Brodrick Bunkley, DT: Someone in the middle could not hurt the Ravens. This pick could also be Cutler since he is slipping, but I think the Ravens will stick with Boller. (Alternate: Jay Cutler, QB)
14 14 Philadelphia - Chad Jackson, WR: TO gone, WR drafted. (Alternate: Ernie Sims, LB)
15 15 Denver - Santonio Holmes, WR: Not sure if Denver would take Holmes here, and would take Jackson if he dropped. The rumor was they wanted to trade up to get Vernon Davis…I don’t think it is happening. Maybe the Broncos take an HB/RB here? Come on, it is the Broncos. (Alternate: DeAngelo Williams, RB)
16 16 Miami - Manny Lawson, DE/OLB: Tough call here. I originally thought of putting Cromartie with the Dolphins, being a prospect that Nick Saban recruited for LSU. OLB seems more of a need though for the Dolphins. (Alternate: Antonio Cromartie, CB, Donte Whitner, S)
17 17 Minnesota - Jay Cutler, QB, Vanderbilt: The Vikings will be glad if he drops to them, but I am thinking they will attempt to move up to get him. If he is here, the Vikings take him. If Cutler is gone, Ernie Sims might be the pick. (Alternate: Ernie Sims, LB)
18 18 Dallas - Ernie Sims, LB: Sims does not drop past the Cowboys. Either Sims or Lawson to play in Dallas’ 3-4 scheme. (Alternate: Donte Whitner, S)
19 19 San Diego - Tye Hill, CB: Good fit to fill a big need. (Alternate: Antonio Cromartie, CB)
20 20 Kansas City - Antonio Cromartie, CB: Went Corner here since two of the top WRs are off the board. Both CB and WR are pressing needs. (Alternate: Tye Hill, CB)
21 21 New England - DeAngelo Williams, RB: Tough pick, but great value - if not then I think the Pats will reach for Demeco Ryans, who they have met with three times. Many drafts have Richard Marshall here, but I think Williams is much better value for the Pats. (Alternate: Demeco Ryans, LB, Bobby Carpenter, LB)
22 22 San Francisco - Mathius Kiwanuka, DE: This is based on the 49ers not getting Mario Williams with the #6 pick. There is a need at DE with the loss of both Andre Carter and Julian Peterson during the off-season. I originally had CB Jonathan Joseph here, but DE seems more pressing. (Alternate: Jonathan Joseph, CB)
23 23 Tampa Bay – Jonathan Joseph, CB: I originally had Eric Winston, OT here, but I read that Tampa Bay signed OT Torrin Tucker, So I am rethinking this pick. Now that I changed my SF pick as well, I think CB would be a good pick here. (Alternate: Eric Winston, OT)
24 24 Cincinnati - Donte Whitner, S: Local guy makes good on the home team. Whitner should be able to play Safety or Cornerback. (Alternate: Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
25 25 N.Y. Giants - Bobby Carpenter, LB: LB was listed as the G-Men’s biggest weakness, so with Carpenter still on the board, it seemed to be a good pick.
26 26 Chicago - Sinorice Moss, WR: I made this pick based on them having Ricky Manning by the draft. WR is still a glaring need, and with two off the board, I think they will pick Moss. (Alternate: Jonathan Joseph, CB, Richard Marshall, CB if Manning is not signed)
27 27 Carolina - Demeco Ryans, LB: Who do you believe…do they take a RB or a LB. If RB, I read that they like Lendale White. They have Foster, so I think they go LB here. (Alternate: LenDale White, RB, Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
28 28 Jacksonville - LenDale White, RB: Just a feeling it would be insurance for Fred Taylor. I kept flip flopping with Thomas Howard here as well. (Alternate: Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
29 29 N.Y. Jets - Chad Greenway, LB: Another player that slid down the draft board. He won’t slip any farther though. (Alternate: Demeco Ryans, LB)
30 30 Indianapolis - Laurence Maroney, RB: Dominic Rhodes will be the starter, but having an additional RB can not hurt the Colts. Three are off the board, so I think they go with Maroney here or trade down to get Joseph Addai. I think there are more LB’s for the Colts to go after than RBs. LB Thomas Howard could be a great pick here if the Colts have faith in their current RBs. (Alternate: Joseph Addai, RB, Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
31 31 Seattle – Kelley Jennings, CB: With a few good CBs left, the Seahawks fill a pressing need in the secondary. I originally had Jason Allen, S here, but think the Seahawks go with a CB. (Alternate: Jason Allen, S)
32 32 Pittsburgh - Jason Allen, S: I originally had Daniel Bullocks, S here, but with my change with the Seahawks, I think Allen will be the choice instead. They could go so many ways, including C, RB or WR. Based on four RBs off the board, and three WRs, I don’t see the Steelers reaching here. (Alternate: Nick Mangold, C)
Edited: I added my commentary, and changed a few picks from my original posted:
22 22 San Francisco - Mathius Kiwanuka, DE (originally Jonathan Joseph, CB)
23 23 Tampa Bay – Jonathan Joseph, CB (originally Eric Winston, OT)
31 31 Seattle – Kelley Jennings, CB (originally Jason Allen, S)
32 32 Pittsburgh - Jason Allen, S (originally Daniel Bullocks, S)
Includes a Viking/Ram trade
Think the Saints/Jet trade and get the players I have them listed with
1 1 Houston - Mario Williams, DE (changed Reggie Bush, RB) - though they should take Williams all along
2 2 New Orleans - D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT (changed Mario Williams) - best player now for the Saints
3 3 Tennessee - Vince Young, QB
4 4 N.Y. Jets - Reggie Bush, RB (changed D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT) - best chance of getting Bush now
5 5 Green Bay - A.J. Hawk, LB
6 6 San Francisco - Vernon Davis, TE
7 7 Oakland - Matt Leinart, QB
8 8 Buffalo - Winston Justice, OT
9 9 Detroit - Michael Huff, S
10 10 Arizona - Ernie Sims, LB (changed Haloti Ngata, DT) - Moving up the board
11 11 (TRADE) Vikings – Jay Cutler, QB
12 12 Cleveland - Haloti Ngata, DT (changed Kamerion Wimbley, DE) - favored over Wimbley
13 13 Baltimore - Brodrick Bunkley, DT
14 14 Philadelphia - Chad Jackson, WR
15 15 Denver - Santonio Holmes, WR
16 16 Miami - Antonio Cromartie, CB (changed Manny Lawson, DE/OLB) - read Miami really wants him
17 17 (TRADE) St. Louis - Jimmy Williams, DB
18 18 Dallas - Manny Lawson, DE/OLB (changed Ernie Sims, LB) - better fit for Dallas anyway
19 19 San Diego - Tye Hill, CB
20 20 Kansas City - Jonathan Joseph, CB (changed Antonio Cromartie, CB) - still need the position
21 21 New England - DeAngelo Williams, RB
22 22 San Francisco - Kamerion Wimbley, DE (changed Mathius Kiwanuka, DE) - Better DE for their system
23 23 Tampa Bay - Mathius Kiwanuka, DE (changed Jonathan Joseph, CB) - fills a need
24 24 Cincinnati - Donte Whitner, S
25 25 N.Y. Giants - Sinorice Moss, WR (changed Bobby Carpenter, LB) - Giants now have Arrington, and does not need Carpenter
26 26 Chicago - S/CB Jason Allen (changed Sinorice Moss, WR) - think the Bears will trade out of this pick altogether
27 27 Carolina - Chad Greenway, LB
28 28 Jacksonville – Thomas Howard, OLB/S
29 29 N.Y. Jets - Bobby Carpenter, LB (changed Demeco Ryans, LB) - Same position, different player
30 30 Indianapolis - Laurence Maroney, RB
31 31 Seattle – Kelley Jennings, CB
32 32 Pittsburgh – LenDale White, RB
______________________________________________________
I thought it would be fun to enter one of the rookie mock drafts online...so here is my rookie attempt at my first rookie mock draft ever!
Mind you, I am not an expert on rookies by any stretch of the imagination. I am posting it here so the experts can show me the error of my ways with picks for there home teams. I looked online at a site that listed the top three weaknesses on each team and made picks based on that.
Here goes:
1 1 Houston - Reggie Bush, RB: Definitely the #1 draft pick of the draft,, but wonder if the Texans really need him and DD? I think the Texans would do better with DE Mario Williams or trade out of this pick. (Alternate pick: Mario Williams, DE)
2 2 New Orleans - Mario Williams, DE: This pick could easily be D'brickashaw Ferguson, but from what I read online, it seems the Saints have Williams and Hawk higher on their draft board. The Saints could move down a few spots and get one of them (trade with Titans or Jets) or you just make the pick right here. With Brees in the fold, I don’t see them going for a QB. (Alternate pick: D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT, A.J. Hawk, LB)
3 3 Tennessee - Vince Young, QB: A lot going on with Tennessee and McNair. I think Volek will start, and groom the next QB. General Manager Floyd Reese likes Vince Young, so that is the pick. If they are not going to pick Leinart, they probably could trade down on this pick to get Young. If Tennessee did pick Leinart, I don’t see the Jets taking Vince Young. (Alternate pick: D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT, Matt Leinart, QB)
4 4 N.Y. Jets - Matt Leinart, QB: I know they now have Pennington and Ramsey, but how to you pass on Leinart especially if you do not have to trade up to get him? (Alternate Pick: D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT, Mario Williams, DE)
5 5 Green Bay - A.J. Hawk, LB: From everything I read, this pick just makes sense. Since I have D'brickashaw Ferguson falling, maybe GB would pick him, but it seems that GB would have to do a lot of shuffling to use him.
6 6 San Francisco - Michael Huff, S: OK, I know everyone else has Vernon Davis here, and it does make sense to give Alex Smith another target to throw at. There are a few other TEs in the draft though, and adding Huff adds to a secondary that lacks both depth and talent. If GB does not take Hawk, he is also another option here. (Alternate pick: Mario Williams, DE, Vernon Davis, TE, A.J. Hawk, LB, D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT)
7 7 Oakland - Vernon Davis, TE: SF loss, Oakland’s gain. Had the Jets not taken Leinart, Oakland would have (don’t read so much into the Aaron Brooks signing, the need is still there). I read if they could not get Leinart or Young here, and Vernon Davis was around, he could be the pick. (Alternate Picks: Matt Leinart, QB, Vince Young, QB, Michael Huff, S)
8 8 Buffalo - D'brickashaw Ferguson, OT: Someone always slips in the draft, and I know Ferguson is the most unlikely, but it is how my draft panned out. Someone might trade up to get him, but I didn’t do any trades in my draft. The Saints, Jets, or GB could easily draft him. He won’t get past Buffalo though. If Ferguson is not the one to side, I think they would still draft position and take Justice. (Alternate: Winston Justice, OT)
9 9 Detroit - Winston Justice, OT: Detroit has a terrible offensive line that could make Justice a starter. (Alternate: Michael Huff, S)
10 10 Arizona - Haloti Ngata, DT: Most Arizona fans don’t think the Cardinals would take Cutler here, so adding a tackle seemed to make sense. Cutler is one of those players that could slide in the draft the same way Rogers did last year. Could the Vikings try to trade up here thinking Arizona will grab Cutler? (Alternate: Jay Cutler, QB)
11 11 St. Louis - Jimmy Williams, DB: I was actually thinking Sims here, but went with Williams. I read that the Rams have quantity vs quality at this position, so Williams should be an upgrade. (Alternate: Ernie Sims, LB, Tye Hill, CB)
12 12 Cleveland - Kamerion Wimbley, DE: Cleveland was looking at Ngata and Wimbley and Wimbley is still here. This pick could also end up being Bunkley in place of Wimbley (Alternate: Brodrick Bunkley, DT)
13 13 Baltimore - Brodrick Bunkley, DT: Someone in the middle could not hurt the Ravens. This pick could also be Cutler since he is slipping, but I think the Ravens will stick with Boller. (Alternate: Jay Cutler, QB)
14 14 Philadelphia - Chad Jackson, WR: TO gone, WR drafted. (Alternate: Ernie Sims, LB)
15 15 Denver - Santonio Holmes, WR: Not sure if Denver would take Holmes here, and would take Jackson if he dropped. The rumor was they wanted to trade up to get Vernon Davis…I don’t think it is happening. Maybe the Broncos take an HB/RB here? Come on, it is the Broncos. (Alternate: DeAngelo Williams, RB)
16 16 Miami - Manny Lawson, DE/OLB: Tough call here. I originally thought of putting Cromartie with the Dolphins, being a prospect that Nick Saban recruited for LSU. OLB seems more of a need though for the Dolphins. (Alternate: Antonio Cromartie, CB, Donte Whitner, S)
17 17 Minnesota - Jay Cutler, QB, Vanderbilt: The Vikings will be glad if he drops to them, but I am thinking they will attempt to move up to get him. If he is here, the Vikings take him. If Cutler is gone, Ernie Sims might be the pick. (Alternate: Ernie Sims, LB)
18 18 Dallas - Ernie Sims, LB: Sims does not drop past the Cowboys. Either Sims or Lawson to play in Dallas’ 3-4 scheme. (Alternate: Donte Whitner, S)
19 19 San Diego - Tye Hill, CB: Good fit to fill a big need. (Alternate: Antonio Cromartie, CB)
20 20 Kansas City - Antonio Cromartie, CB: Went Corner here since two of the top WRs are off the board. Both CB and WR are pressing needs. (Alternate: Tye Hill, CB)
21 21 New England - DeAngelo Williams, RB: Tough pick, but great value - if not then I think the Pats will reach for Demeco Ryans, who they have met with three times. Many drafts have Richard Marshall here, but I think Williams is much better value for the Pats. (Alternate: Demeco Ryans, LB, Bobby Carpenter, LB)
22 22 San Francisco - Mathius Kiwanuka, DE: This is based on the 49ers not getting Mario Williams with the #6 pick. There is a need at DE with the loss of both Andre Carter and Julian Peterson during the off-season. I originally had CB Jonathan Joseph here, but DE seems more pressing. (Alternate: Jonathan Joseph, CB)
23 23 Tampa Bay – Jonathan Joseph, CB: I originally had Eric Winston, OT here, but I read that Tampa Bay signed OT Torrin Tucker, So I am rethinking this pick. Now that I changed my SF pick as well, I think CB would be a good pick here. (Alternate: Eric Winston, OT)
24 24 Cincinnati - Donte Whitner, S: Local guy makes good on the home team. Whitner should be able to play Safety or Cornerback. (Alternate: Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
25 25 N.Y. Giants - Bobby Carpenter, LB: LB was listed as the G-Men’s biggest weakness, so with Carpenter still on the board, it seemed to be a good pick.
26 26 Chicago - Sinorice Moss, WR: I made this pick based on them having Ricky Manning by the draft. WR is still a glaring need, and with two off the board, I think they will pick Moss. (Alternate: Jonathan Joseph, CB, Richard Marshall, CB if Manning is not signed)
27 27 Carolina - Demeco Ryans, LB: Who do you believe…do they take a RB or a LB. If RB, I read that they like Lendale White. They have Foster, so I think they go LB here. (Alternate: LenDale White, RB, Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
28 28 Jacksonville - LenDale White, RB: Just a feeling it would be insurance for Fred Taylor. I kept flip flopping with Thomas Howard here as well. (Alternate: Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
29 29 N.Y. Jets - Chad Greenway, LB: Another player that slid down the draft board. He won’t slip any farther though. (Alternate: Demeco Ryans, LB)
30 30 Indianapolis - Laurence Maroney, RB: Dominic Rhodes will be the starter, but having an additional RB can not hurt the Colts. Three are off the board, so I think they go with Maroney here or trade down to get Joseph Addai. I think there are more LB’s for the Colts to go after than RBs. LB Thomas Howard could be a great pick here if the Colts have faith in their current RBs. (Alternate: Joseph Addai, RB, Thomas Howard, OLB/S)
31 31 Seattle – Kelley Jennings, CB: With a few good CBs left, the Seahawks fill a pressing need in the secondary. I originally had Jason Allen, S here, but think the Seahawks go with a CB. (Alternate: Jason Allen, S)
32 32 Pittsburgh - Jason Allen, S: I originally had Daniel Bullocks, S here, but with my change with the Seahawks, I think Allen will be the choice instead. They could go so many ways, including C, RB or WR. Based on four RBs off the board, and three WRs, I don’t see the Steelers reaching here. (Alternate: Nick Mangold, C)
Edited: I added my commentary, and changed a few picks from my original posted:
22 22 San Francisco - Mathius Kiwanuka, DE (originally Jonathan Joseph, CB)
23 23 Tampa Bay – Jonathan Joseph, CB (originally Eric Winston, OT)
31 31 Seattle – Kelley Jennings, CB (originally Jason Allen, S)
32 32 Pittsburgh - Jason Allen, S (originally Daniel Bullocks, S)
Last edited by a moderator: