This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
I think for a contending team getting Hilton for 2.12 is a STEAL, where I guess if I'm rebuilding then I'd prefer the pick...but I think Hilton and Cooks are both WRs that are better than current "perceived" value based on last years down year for them both.Dacomish said:
I was going to say Hilton easily but then noticed it as IDP and I don't play IDP so in hindsight probably should not have even responded but already started, just not sure how IDP impacts the rookie pool down to pick 24.Dacomish said:
2.1/3.2 in first trade. Have made my feelings known on Mostert.
I was offered that by an owner who likes Chark even more than I do, which I didn't expect. I had recently gotten the 1.10 back in a deal where I big time overpaid for AJ Brown, so I was happy to (seemingly) gain some value back. FWIW the owner said he chose to send this offer to me over accepting an offer of Mixon and 2.09 he had received from someone else. He sees Chark as a top-5 WR the next 5 years.
So you don't think Hardman is the #2 starting WR with Mahomes for the foreseeable future? I assumed Watkins is gone and he'd be the starter with Hill. And of course IF Hill gets in trouble again (I'm not wishing that at all) he would become even more valuable. So am I over valuing Hardman here?
I think it was a fairly close deal, but I don’t think it’s a certainty that Hardman is the WR2 there if Watkins leaves. He seems redundant to Hill as a starter and I could see a bigger WR in free agency or the draft coming in. Plus Kelce is the real no. 2 receiver there anyway.I didn't even realize how little he was utilized in the playoffs until just now after looking at the box scores...now I'm feeling REALLY stupid....
Ok so maybe you gave up some value here but there is a bright side-I didn't even realize how little he was utilized in the playoffs until just now after looking at the box scores...now I'm feeling REALLY stupid....
Redundant to Hill as if that would be a bad thing?
A lesser version that does the same thing isn’t an ideal no. 2 was all I was saying. If he was every bit as good as Hill of course it would be a good thing - but he’s better suited to be the WR3 imo.
Yep good deal. I think the value is on the other side but I think you are maximizing your starting lineup points, which is more important. I think it's worth losing a little value on paper (debatable here) if it means gaining a stud. 1.02 has a much higher chance of doing that, especially at RB.
I like Slayton a lot but I think I like what I can get at 1.11 a little better. I'm not real big on Hardman and I would try really hard to counter for a different piece. Even a future 2nd would probably do it for me. I agree he can be the #2 WR (as mentioned Kelce is the #1 or #2 target) but I just don't think that's going to blossom into a big enough role to start on my squads. Even so I imagine I could flip Hardman for a little something and be fine with it, because I would probably take the 1.11 regardless, and I do really like Slayton a bit.
I'll take the Cook side... Even if the pick is 2020 2.01, but assuming you meant 2021 2nd.
I like it. Edelman's value is year to year but that year might go poof without Brady.
I like it it for you especially with your stated RB need.
I would prefer the Amari side on this deal even if I thought Isabella was not worthy of a roster spot, which I don't, and might have to struggle to find room to roster Jones but while I value the 2.2 and like Robinson I just like Amari more.
Agreed. He's good no doubt, when he's available. But I think there's at least three or four guys in this draft that can be worth equal to or more than him in a year. And you get Hunt who I still value as a late 1st or so and a next year 2nd? Give me that side all day.
I think that's gross. This is the rare "I break the keyboard hitting accept". For Juju. I kind of like Brown but nope.
I've been trying to buy high on Cook in a couple spots to no avail. But I think 1.01 is about equal to him right now. I don't feel the same about 1.02. This is a free Hunt and 2nd to me.
I've been thinking that all offseason except I own him everywhere already. I'm actually a little perturbed that I can't go after him. And I'm not even sure he is going to be in a sweet enough spot in redraft for me to go for him there either.
Yes Dalvin is very good but the injuries are one issue. Some other minor issues as well ranging from potential holdout to Vikings being so up against the cap they got to let him walk next year and while the OL for the Vikings may not be great I think the system is pretty ideal for him.
I think I like the Thielen side by a good deal. This class is deep, but so few wr prospects pop early, if you can skip a developmental guy and add a proven guy like thielen to an already solid team, thats a win.
