Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Any player I'm paying 2 first rounders for in dynasty better be a 1st round pick in redraft. That's my value system at least. Hell, I got 2 firsts for Hopkins, and he's likely to be a top 3 WR. Age is obviously in Gibson's favor, but we're also talking about a RB (shorter careers) and not even a "feature back" since McKissic isn't going anywhere & gets the bulk of the receptions, or in an "elite" offense (we just don't know what this offense is going to be with Fitz/Heineken).I wouldn't pay 2 1sts for him personally as I'm not that high on him. He wasn't the work horse in college and got hurt his 1st year already in the pros. However, I think that is what his value is at. I wouldn't sell him for less than 2 1sts or top 3-4 pick this year but I don't have any stake in him at all. In PPR, he is ranked as a 2nd round pick in redraft....not sure that is "depressed." Plus, he is young and showed promise.
2x firsts is a head scratcher for me. I like Gibson a lot more than I did when he first popped - he's fun to watch. But hey, I don't judge folks for who they value and how. If folks are selling for 2 firsts, good for them.