***Official*** Holy Grail Redux WW Game Thread (2 Viewers)

[Norman Einstein]

debating whether or not to reveal my moment of clarity regarding foos....

Pretty much his exchange with IB a few days back.

Something was definitely off.

Both end up being anti-villa

It was a fair cop

not it

 

[McGarnicle]

oops, sorry I see I'm dead.

God my ###.

 

[Merlin]

Two PEASANTS knock them away with sledge hammers. The GIRL and the duck

swing slightly but balance perfectly.

ALL

A witch! A witch!

WITCH

It's a fair cop.

All

Burn her! Burn her! Let's make her into a ladder.

 

[OC Zed]

after foos claimed he needed a trigger i asked brent yesterday if he was thinking what I was thinking. He said yes but it would be risky. That was about giving the grail to foos. Then I asked everyone else so it wouldn't be clear what we had been talking about.

I asked foos what kind of event triggered his powers and he just said not allowed to tell but if you watch the movie it would be obvious. There was only one scene in the movie and it wasn't obvious except that he told Arthur to get the grail.

I sent the grail to IB so i could ask more questions today and he could decide. But it went random. then brent said out loud that the item was the holy grail, and foos didn't blink. And then the grenade didn't even work so apparently it had gone to foos, yet he still didn't comment on whether that was the trigger for his supposed powers. So this was a slam dunk imo.

I tend to believe brent is good. He's way down on my suspect list right now. If he was bad, he would have known foos had the protection item and wouldn't have minded using the grenade. But if you were going to make that move, you'd think that brent would have tried to make some lemonade from their recent lemons. another check in the brent is a gg list imo

Sorry, spent just about all of yesterday skimming, but who had the grenade when it was pulled and didn't hit anyone?

 

[Merlin]

debating whether or not to reveal my moment of clarity regarding foos....

Pretty much his exchange with IB a few days back.

Something was definitely off.

Both end up being anti-villa

It was a fair cop

not it

It was for me.

You on the other hand have been on your reads

Kudos GB

 

[Norman Einstein]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

 

[Sand]

1. FatUncleJerryBus - claims Cart Master

3. Lambskin

9. Zed
11. mexiJoe

17. Hagmania - claims Sir Galahad

20. EG

25. bostonfred

27. Merlin

29. witz

30. Sand

33. McGarnicle - claims PJB

35. Hodor

38. norm

Since page one is a few nights behind, I think this is the current list.

 

[Sand]

after foos claimed he needed a trigger i asked brent yesterday if he was thinking what I was thinking. He said yes but it would be risky. That was about giving the grail to foos. Then I asked everyone else so it wouldn't be clear what we had been talking about.

I asked foos what kind of event triggered his powers and he just said not allowed to tell but if you watch the movie it would be obvious. There was only one scene in the movie and it wasn't obvious except that he told Arthur to get the grail.

I sent the grail to IB so i could ask more questions today and he could decide. But it went random. then brent said out loud that the item was the holy grail, and foos didn't blink. And then the grenade didn't even work so apparently it had gone to foos, yet he still didn't comment on whether that was the trigger for his supposed powers. So this was a slam dunk imo.

I tend to believe brent is good. He's way down on my suspect list right now. If he was bad, he would have known foos had the protection item and wouldn't have minded using the grenade. But if you were going to make that move, you'd think that brent would have tried to make some lemonade from their recent lemons. another check in the brent is a gg list imo

Sorry, spent just about all of yesterday skimming, but who had the grenade when it was pulled and didn't hit anyone?

Hodor had it yesterday. He did his Foos, but Foos was a BGRP and shrugged it off. The village then lynched foos.

 

[Merlin]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

I was taught during this game.

Click on the players name.

Click on content ( upper right side )

Click on "posts only" ( left side )

 

[Sand]

hit

 

[CGRdrJoe]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

Nope, pretty much have to go page to page.

 

[McGarnicle]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

I'd be curious to see if I accused more or less than 38 players of being bad at some point.

 

[CGRdrJoe]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

I was taught during this game.

Click on the players name.

Click on content ( upper right side )

Click on "posts only" ( left side )

 

[Merlin]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

I was taught during this game.

Click on the players name.

Click on FIND content ( upper right side )

Click on "posts only" ( left side )

added and fixed

 

[Merlin]

is there a way to search for posts from people within this thread

I was taught during this game.

Click on the players name.

Click on content ( upper right side )

Click on "posts only" ( left side )

I know, right.

Things have changed in the year or so since I hung out here.

The Cheese, somebody move it.

 

[Idiot Boxer]

after foos claimed he needed a trigger i asked brent yesterday if he was thinking what I was thinking. He said yes but it would be risky. That was about giving the grail to foos. Then I asked everyone else so it wouldn't be clear what we had been talking about.

I asked foos what kind of event triggered his powers and he just said not allowed to tell but if you watch the movie it would be obvious. There was only one scene in the movie and it wasn't obvious except that he told Arthur to get the grail.

I sent the grail to IB so i could ask more questions today and he could decide. But it went random. then brent said out loud that the item was the holy grail, and foos didn't blink. And then the grenade didn't even work so apparently it had gone to foos, yet he still didn't comment on whether that was the trigger for his supposed powers. So this was a slam dunk imo.

I tend to believe brent is good. He's way down on my suspect list right now. If he was bad, he would have known foos had the protection item and wouldn't have minded using the grenade. But if you were going to make that move, you'd think that brent would have tried to make some lemonade from their recent lemons. another check in the brent is a gg list imo

Just so I'm reading this right (and because I don't track aliases) IB = Brent?

I wish.

*sorry. Dead shall ####. Not posting anything game related. I just wish I were as awesome as Brent*

 

[Norman Einstein]

these are bolded in the writeups so we know they are in the game:

BROTHER MAYNARD

LANCELOT

CONCORD -- Sinn

Black Knight

Tim the Enchanter -- ib

BRIDGEKEEPER -- rascal

ARTHUR

Sir Bedevere

Sir Not-appearing-in-this-film -- belljr

ROBIN -- bryhamm

dead guys not bolded in writeup but revealed on death:

Dennis -- Sacramento Bob GGRP

Black Beast of Auuughh -- magichat BGRP

Knight of Ni -- icon BGRP

Three-Headed Knight -- loansharks BGRP

French Guard -- Black Box BGRP.

Zoot -- Foos BGRP

claims not mentioned in writeups or reveals:

Cart Master -- FUJB

Sir Galahad -- Hagmania

so with these it appears there are

9 ggrp's bolded/revealed/claimed

7 bgrp's bolded/revealed

1 neutral bolded/revealed

1 bolded/indy

updated.

maybe there's additional roles yet revealed, but it doesn't seem equal without knowing what everyone does...just numbers-wise

 

[Evilgrin 72]

these are bolded in the writeups so we know they are in the game:

BROTHER MAYNARD

LANCELOT

CONCORD -- Sinn

Black Knight

Tim the Enchanter -- ib

BRIDGEKEEPER -- rascal

ARTHUR

Sir Bedevere

Sir Not-appearing-in-this-film -- belljr

ROBIN -- bryhamm

dead guys not bolded in writeup but revealed on death:

Dennis -- Sacramento Bob GGRP

Black Beast of Auuughh -- magichat BGRP

Knight of Ni -- icon BGRP

Three-Headed Knight -- loansharks BGRP

French Guard -- Black Box BGRP.

Zoot -- Foos BGRP

claims not mentioned in writeups or reveals:

Cart Master -- FUJB

Sir Galahad -- Hagmania

so with these it appears there are

9 ggrp's bolded/revealed/claimed

7 bgrp's bolded/revealed

1 neutral bolded/revealed

1 bolded/indy

updated.

maybe there's additional roles yet revealed, but it doesn't seem equal without knowing what everyone does...just numbers-wise

9 GGRPs, 9 BGRPs, 2 neutral/indy and 20 PJBs makes perfect sense to me mathematically in a 40 person game. Have we killed 6 or 7 BGs at this point?

 

[Dan Lambskin]

Would Rabbit be in play as a BGRP?

 

[Evilgrin 72]

these are bolded in the writeups so we know they are in the game:

BROTHER MAYNARD

LANCELOT

CONCORD -- Sinn

Black Knight

Tim the Enchanter -- ib

BRIDGEKEEPER -- rascal

ARTHUR

Sir Bedevere

Sir Not-appearing-in-this-film -- belljr

ROBIN -- bryhamm

dead guys not bolded in writeup but revealed on death:

Dennis -- Sacramento Bob GGRP

Black Beast of Auuughh -- magichat BGRP

Knight of Ni -- icon BGRP

Three-Headed Knight -- loansharks BGRP

French Guard -- Black Box BGRP.

Zoot -- Foos BGRP

claims not mentioned in writeups or reveals:

Cart Master -- FUJB

Sir Galahad -- Hagmania

so with these it appears there are

9 ggrp's bolded/revealed/claimed

7 bgrp's bolded/revealed

1 neutral bolded/revealed

1 bolded/indy

updated.

maybe there's additional roles yet revealed, but it doesn't seem equal without knowing what everyone does...just numbers-wise

9 GGRPs, 9 BGRPs, 2 neutral/indy and 20 PJBs makes perfect sense to me mathematically in a 40 person game. Have we killed 6 or 7 BGs at this point?

By my count 6 (plus Belljr) so we probably face 3 remaining BGs.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

Would Rabbit be in play as a BGRP?

Mos def

 

[Norman Einstein]

these are bolded in the writeups so we know they are in the game:

BROTHER MAYNARD

LANCELOT

CONCORD -- Sinn

Black Knight

Tim the Enchanter -- ib

BRIDGEKEEPER -- rascal

ARTHUR

Sir Bedevere

Sir Not-appearing-in-this-film -- belljr

ROBIN -- bryhamm

dead guys not bolded in writeup but revealed on death:

Dennis -- Sacramento Bob GGRP

Black Beast of Auuughh -- magichat BGRP

Knight of Ni -- icon BGRP

Three-Headed Knight -- loansharks BGRP

French Guard -- Black Box BGRP.

Zoot -- Foos BGRP

claims not mentioned in writeups or reveals:

Cart Master -- FUJB

Sir Galahad -- Hagmania

so with these it appears there are

9 ggrp's bolded/revealed/claimed

7 bgrp's bolded/revealed

1 neutral bolded/revealed

1 bolded/indy

updated.

maybe there's additional roles yet revealed, but it doesn't seem equal without knowing what everyone does...just numbers-wise

9 GGRPs, 9 BGRPs, 2 neutral/indy and 20 PJBs makes perfect sense to me mathematically in a 40 person game. Have we killed 6 or 7 BGs at this point?

looks like 6 bgs...not sure how to classify belljr.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

1. FatUncleJerryBus - claims Cart Master

3. Lambskin

9. Zed
11. mexiJoe

17. Hagmania - claims Sir Galahad

20. EG

25. bostonfred

27. Merlin

29. witz

30. Sand

33. McGarnicle - claims PJB

35. Hodor

38. norm

Absent a counter, I feel pretty good about Cav and Hag. I'd be shocked if Norm or McGarnicle was a BG. I feel pretty good about Fred and Hodor. Tend GG on Dan Lambskin. Neutral on Mex.

Merlin

Witz

Sand

Zed

IMO, 2 or 3 of the remaining BGs are in that group of 4.

We have to be nearing seer coming out (if he's not already dead) and/or mass claim time.

 

[CGRdrJoe]

Don't forget about the player that could be changed to a bg

 

[Evilgrin 72]

Don't forget about the player that could be changed to a bg

You don't think that was Bell?

 

[CGRdrJoe]

Don't forget about the player that could be changed to a bg

You don't think that was Bell?

Ah, I dIdnt connect it to sir not appearing in this film.

 

[Merlin]

Don't forget about the player that could be changed to a bg

That would be belljr, imo

 

[Merlin]

Don't forget about the player that could be changed to a bg

You don't think that was Bell?

This

 

[McGarnicle]

What's all this about countering/counters?

 

[Merlin]

What's all this about countering/counters?

Sometimes a BG will claim a role ( Angel ) or a role name ( Red Riding Hood ) expected to be in the game.

The GGRP with the role or role name may or may not come out and "counter" the claim.

 

[Merlin]

And in the reverse, a BG may try to "counter" in an effort to get the original claimer lynched.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

What's all this about countering/counters?

If someone were to pop up now and say : "Hey, FUJB is full of antelope shit ! I'm the cart master, beotch !" that would be a counter-claim or counter. Then, we'd have to decide who was lying. If someone claims a role you know is in the game and nobody ever pops up to counter that claim, you can rest pretty well assured that the original claim is legit.

 

[Evilgrin 72]

vote culdeus

 

[Merlin]

vote culdeus

Flashbacks from 'Nam, GB ?

 

[OC Zed]

I have to get my daughter up and ready for school and drive her over, so I'm likely out for the next 90 minutes or so.

Hopefully not flat tires on the way. I just bought a new set last month, so I'm assuming there is some kind of warranty.

 

[McGarnicle]

I have to get my daughter up and ready for school and drive her over, so I'm likely out for the next 90 minutes or so.

Hopefully not flat tires on the way. I just bought a new set last month, so I'm assuming there is some kind of warranty.

Ever hear of Uber? IMO.

 

[Norman Einstein]

ok how about these on gg side

sacbob

merls

mcgarncle

fujb

acer

harry

bry

eg

fred

oczed

yuk

hulk -- bg hulk likes to porove his ggishness...he hasnt done anything that i recall

im going to add bucky and spoofy back to this as they were also gg

the dan guy seems lost so hes probably a gg unless really playing that up

probably something like

rascal

foos

blackbox

hodor

maybe icon....

adding hagmania...wheres the shtck? hes too "by the vest" this game imo

sand

loansharks

witz

near the bgside

undecided

worm

ib

conn

fatguy

magic

bellj

cgrdr

nothing changed yet...just bumping so i can find it

checking out those still left

 

[Norman Einstein]

ok, one update...

sand moved to gg side

 

[McGarnicle]

ok, one update...

sand moved to gg side

What changed?

 

[Norman Einstein]

i just can't wrap my head around hags claim. wouldn't other's be also searching for the grail. or is it possible that only one guy is doing it?

just seems odd

 

[Norman Einstein]

ok, one update...

sand moved to gg side

What changed?

you'll just have to trust me on this one

 

[bostonfred]

Yeah hags is probably fos.

 

[Merlin]

i just can't wrap my head around hags claim. wouldn't other's be also searching for the grail. or is it possible that only one guy is doing it?

just seems odd

The movie, as well as the legend, is about all of the Knights of the Roundtable questing for the Grail.

Having found it, Galahad the Chaste desires to ascend to Heaven.

Not sure how that relates to "joining" Arthur on a mason board.

Seems a bit of a stretch, imo

 

[Merlin]

Joining Foos would have made more sense

 

[Evilgrin 72]

I forgot we have unrevealed corpses. Makes it trickier to confirm FUJB or Hags.

 

[Hodor]

Morning Gents

 

[Evilgrin 72]

Morning Gents

Hodor

 

[bostonfred]

not likely but technically we could win tonight

 

[Evilgrin 72]

not likely but technically we could win tonight

LF vig takes out someone and the remaining BGs commit harikari like Nigel and I did in that game years ago?

 

[hagmania]

i just can't wrap my head around hags claim. wouldn't other's be also searching for the grail. or is it possible that only one guy is doing it?

just seems odd

The movie, as well as the legend, is about all of the Knights of the Roundtable questing for the Grail.

Having found it, Galahad the Chaste desires to ascend to Heaven.

Not sure how that relates to "joining" Arthur on a mason board.

Seems a bit of a stretch, imo

Dennis was just a peasant, he could never have gained executive power "in the movie"

My role fits the theme well enough. Galahad was the most fervent about searching for the Grail.