***Official Luck v. RG3 Thread*** (1 Viewer)

[cobalt_27]

I'm very intrigued by both of these guys and how they'll translate to the NFL level. Both seem like incredibly smart guys. Any obvious reason(s) to favor one over the other?

 

[CalBear]

I think Luck is marginally more likely to be successful than Griffin; say, 60% probability compared to 45%. It's hard not to take Luck ahead of Griffin, but if you can get a boatload of picks plus Griffin for Luck, it's gotta make better sense to go for Griffin.

 

[Dr. Awesome]

Real life: Luck

Fantasy: Griffin

 

[cobalt_27]

Any significant concerns with luck in either regard?

How about RG3?

I worry, for example, that Luck might be too mechanical and content to play it safe. Not aggressive. Risk-averse.

With Griffin, is he injury prone or about to be? Inflated numbers due to circumstance, competition? Also, sort of a funky release.

Mind you, both look like awesome talents in their own right. To me, anyway. Just trying to figure out what's worth nitpicking and what's safe to feel good about.

 

[Area51Inhabitant]

Luck is the sure thing in this draft but Griffin could wind up exceeding him in both real life and Fantasy. For Griffin's sake, I hope he doesn't end up in Cleveland or Washington and winds up going to a better run Organization.