Ghost Rider said:
If I am the NFL, I call Brady's bluff and make him take them to court, where all of his texts and whatnot will come out, likely showing that he was complicit in some manner.
100% agree, he's bluffing.
But even if that's wrong there's no chance Brady will challenge the findings in court. He'll just challenge the procedure. The last thing Brady wants is to go through disclosure or have to choose between telling the truth or perjuring himself.
IMO most likely outcome is this is wrapped up just in time for the season to start. At some point you have to show your cards or fold.
If I am Brady's defense team, I would argue that "even if Brady knew" or "even if he somehow were found to have participated," it doesn't change that:
- The Wells report has more holes than Swiss cheese. The data for the AFCCG does not conclusively show the footballs were artifically deflated.
- The league has a history of giving people/teams warnings and not suspensions.
-
The infraction fell under the auspices of an equipment violation, which historically has met with a minimal fine.
- Other teams have been caught in the act manipulating footballs and nothing happened to them.
- The league never gave a rat's ### about football inflation until the AFCCG.
- Refuing to turn over a cell phone = $50,000 fine, precident already set.
It is in Brady's best interest to drag this out, as it could take forever to play itself through the court system. With an injunction, Brady could continue to play. If he were to get hurt, if NE had already wrapped up a bye, if they hit an easy stretch in their schedule, Brady could snap his fingers and drop his lawsuit and take the penalty (especially if it was trimmed to one or two games). It IS NOT in his (or the team's) best intererst to have to sit at the start of the season. Strategically, there are other games that would not make as big an impact on NE's chances of winning or losing those games. And if he really wanted to, I don't think it would be that hard to get everything stretched out until after the season is over the way courts work.
I also am not fully aware of the rules / guidelines / laws with regard to providing access to a personal cell phone. It doesn't sound like there is a law that requires Brady to hand over his phone. Is there a clause in the CBA that states he MUST hand over his phone?