'the spanker said:
'NCPanthersFan said:
All of this comes down to your own personal opinion of how you think Charles is going come back. I don't think the topic stands on its own otherwise as the two players are not even remotely close in talent. So IMHO a bandwagon for Hillis is the same bandwagon that is rooting for Charles to have some unforeseen problems.
Charles has not had a single setback and by all accounts is back in good health. With that in mind I think it would be tough to project his carries for anything less than 200-220 - remember he has had plenty of rehab time.
So what does that leave Hillis?
It looks like he is going to be a great utility player behind the best OL?? of his career. I would think 200 carries is a lofty number (175 seems more like it) but there is probably 5-6 rushing TD's available for him to grab. Figure 18-23 catches.
RB 3-4 in my book.
Chiefs have already stated they plan to run 500 times.
The best laid plans of mice and men....Using that reasoning, Shonn greene is the guy you want in fantasy because the Jets have said they plan to run it all day and all night and they don't have to share carries much.
I think a few components that are really under-talked about in all this are:
1)Can the team REALLY run that much? I'm sure they CAN in theory but they might also have to be pretty fortunate that the game plan goes well, the defense keeps them in their games early, etc because
they play in a division where all those teams can get points on you in a hurry and they play games against the Falcons, Saints, and
Panthers this year where its not hard to envision having to pass to keep up. So, that's 9-10 games this year where I'm really calling that into question. Just hard for me to imagine the Chiefs going down to the dome in New orleans and running the ball down the saints throat all day. So I'm more inclined to think there will be situaitonal spots where this works but a lot of games where it simply won't hold up.
2)How well does Hillis have to perform to really eat that type of time share into Charles? If he is rumbling and knocking people over at 4.5+ yards a pop, sure. But if he is out there picking up 3 yards a carry and charles is out there doing what he does; gashing teams for 6-7 yards a pop and catching passes and being a legit threat to score each time, I think its hard to be on that field calling plays that don't utilize your best weapon half the time.