Pick a QB to keep (1 Viewer)

[Patriots24]

.5 pt per comp, 1pt per 20 yds 6 pts per TD

Derek Carr or Dak Prescott? I've been holding onto Carr since his rookie year and now he's having a great season, but the rookie season Dak is having is amazing. Who is the better QB for the future?

 

[themeistersinger]

I think Derek Carr has far more upside.  The Raiders O line is almost as good as the Cowboys, and with Zeke out there the Cowboys will always have a reason to hand off in any situation.  As good as Dak has been, he hasn't been forced to beat a top defense yet - no Seahawks or Broncos or Vikings on his schedule (although Minny next week).  Carr has had to face off against the Broncos twice a year - had to be a good education there.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751681-should-i-start-diggs-if-he-is-active-thursday-whir/

 

[CaptainJT]

I am assuming this is a dynasty league.  I think I would hold onto Carr.   He has an offense built around him and sould continue to throw for huge numbers (except for his game vs Denver).   

My suggestion for you would be to try and trade Prescott.  He is playing very well and has a bright future.  Trade him to someone in your league.  Do you have to drop him?

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/751685-kicker-questions-are-sexy-right-i-will-answer-yours/ (please provide your advice)

 

[Tmw1034]

Tough call. I assume by your question that you cannot keep both? I like CaptainJT's advice on this one. I think the market for either of those guys might be pretty strong for a trade. If I'm picking one right now, I think I'd lean Carr. He's been steadily improving since coming into the league. Dak may well do the same, but a little more unknown with him at this point. I'm not sure you can go wrong though.