Please rank your Dynasty rookie top 5 picks- non PPR (1 Viewer)

[El Floppo]

Non PPR Dynasty league (standard scoring otherwise) with 12 teams.

How do you rank the top 5 picks?

 

[Gally]

Depends on my needs of course:

If I am set at RB I would go this route:

1. M. Williams
   
2. C. Davis
   
3. McCaffrey
   
4. Fournette
   
5. Cook
   

If I need RB I would go this route:

1. McCaffrey
   
2. Fournette
   
3. Cook
   
4. Mixon
   
5. M. Williams
   

In a 2QB league where I need a QB:

1. McCaffrey
   
2. Fournette
   
3. M. Williams
   
4. Cook
   
5. Watson
   

 

[El Floppo]

Depends on my needs of course:

If I need RB I would go this route:

1. McCaffrey
   
2. Fournette
   
3. Cook
   
4. Mixon
   
5. M. Williams
   

imagine more of the above.

Interesting to see McCaffrey #1 in a non-PPR... can you talk more about this? ftr- I'm just starting my rookie research and know next to nothing about these guys except the obvious talking points.

 

[cfoster9]

1. Fournette

2. Davis

3. Cook

4. Mixon

5. McCaffery/Williams

Being non-PPR really hurts the value of McCaffery in my eyes. Think he will be valuable and used a ton but not sure how much he will score.  

 

[Gally]

imagine more of the above.

Interesting to see McCaffrey #1 in a non-PPR... can you talk more about this? ftr- I'm just starting my rookie research and know next to nothing about these guys except the obvious talking points.

I see McCaffrey being used all over the field and Stewart has a huge injury history.  I see the Panthers bouncing back offensively and I think they will use McCaffrey in many aspects (not just receiving).  He is easily the top pick for me in PPR, but I also think he gets enough touches to be an all around fantasy threat from the get go.

 

[Warhogs]

Mine seem to be moving around a bit each day but at this time:

Fournette

Cook

McCaffrey

Mixon

Davis

I tend to have to give more RB an edge in my non-ppr leagues.

 

[Spike]

Fournette

Mixon

McCaffrey

Cook

Davis

 

[Mark Football]

Fournette

Mixon

McCaffery

Cook

Davis