PPR - I. Smith or D Foreman, Which One Do You Like (1 Viewer)

[jwsbowler]

This is a simple question.  PPR league... Do you want Foreman or Smith?  I have Foreman and was offered Smith.  The other owner has L Miller.  I am torn here as I think value side, Smith is the right one, but I really like Foreman even with his past injury.  Currently, at RB, I have:  Gurley, Henderson, Henry, Davis, Samuel, and Sanders with Foreman.

 

[pkroper22]

I think I would prefer Foreman, even with that achilles injury.  Smith is a smaller back and I don't believe will ever be a guy that receives the lion's share of carries.  The Falcons also drafted a bigger back in Ollison who could very well get the carries if/when Freeman goes down again.

Foreman had started to "flash" before his injury and he is the handcuff to Miller.  Miller is nothing great, so I think Foreman has decent shot at surpassing Miller.

All-in-all, I think there is a much greater reward in Foreman than Smith.

 

[Cjw_55106]

Personally, I wouldn't have much use for Smith. Id ask for a 2020 second rounder instead.

 

[jtbreidert]

I agree with these guys.  I like Foreman.  Smith will be a decent change of pace guy with Freeman back.  Foreman will be the guy soon in Houston. You're so strong at RB, though, that I think I'd try to get a trade for Foreman that includes help at other positions.

 

[Gally]

I would rather have Foreman in a 1for1 deal.  I would need something more than Smith to make that deal.

 

[jwsbowler]

Thanks everyone...