QB question - p/u T.Taylor? (1 Viewer)

[Irishod]

Should I pick up Taylor (v Cleveland) or go with one of Jameis Winston (v Dallas) or Eli (v Detroit)?

 

[codyiii420]

Tyrod could have a hayday.

 

[Rubi]

Eli.....shhhhhhhh.....I heard it from a friend who heard it from a friend who heard it from another The Giants are coming out throwing against The Lions.

 

[Houston turmOiler]

I like Taylor. Too much upside against a bad defense. Eli and Winston are playing much better defenses and lack that upside IMO

 

[Long Ball Larry]

Struggling with Tyrod vs. Winston myself.

I kind of see them both with the same floor.  

Maybe Tyrod comes out and lights up the Browns.  I think that his true ceiling is probably higher that Jameis.

But I am super worried that Buf just runs it all day in the bad weather.  and Jameis might have to make some things happen in order to win the game.

So, HTH...

 

[ragone]

I'm struggling with Taylor Vs Kaepernick Vs Flacco Myself..

 

[Irishod]

My worry with Jameis is that Dallas may dominate time of possession and limit Winston's chances.

 

[Long Ball Larry]

My worry with Jameis is that Dallas may dominate time of possession and limit Winston's chances.

I definitely think that the possibility of this happening is real.

for me, it is coming down to the weather in buffalo and Tyrod's general poor play over the past several weeks, plus they have not been doing that many designed runs.

so I think that tyrod's ceiling is higher given the matchup, but the chances that he hits that (or even a good game) are lower than the chances that Winston has a good to very good game.

like tyrods range is 4-40 and jameis is 10-30.  And there is like a 50-60% chance that jameis is in the higher half of that range and about a 25% chance that tyrod equals or exceeds that.

this is mostly me continuing to think through my own decision ...