Rank these RBs (1 Viewer)

[bucsbaby]

Using this scoring system:

1/10 yds rushing

1/10 yds receiving

.5/reception

6/TD

-2/fumble

please rank these RBs:

McGahee

Addai

L. Johnson

Portis

Gore

A. Peterson

Barber

Thanks!

 

[bucsbaby]

Sorry, I posted this in the wrong forum by mistake, if a moderator could move it, I would appreciate it. Thanks

 

[munchkin]

Using this scoring system:1/10 yds rushing1/10 yds receiving.5/reception6/TD-2/fumbleplease rank these RBs:McGaheeAddaiL. JohnsonPortisGoreA. Peterson BarberThanks!

ADP (It's ADP. LT and Westbrook)Gore (Gore is the man in the backfield while Addai splits time.)Addai (How many systems would he be a great back in?)Portis (Best years are behind him but has more moves than Fred Astaire.)LJ (I know most people will have him last but I think he has a lot to prove after getting a big contract then getting hurt.)Barber (If his body could withstand his intensity over 16 games he could be 2nd or 3rd on this list.)McGhee (On again off again runner.)

 

[bucsbaby]

Do you think moving McGahee + ? for Portis would be a move to make or does sitting tight on McGahee seem reasonable?

 

[a_troll00]

Do you think moving McGahee + ? for Portis would be a move to make or does sitting tight on McGahee seem reasonable?

I'm having a difficult time gauging McGahee right now. The coaches say he will have an increased workload, but he will be seeing eight in the box for much of the season.

 

[ajopiela]

Using this scoring system:1/10 yds rushing1/10 yds receiving.5/reception6/TD-2/fumbleplease rank these RBs:McGaheeAddaiL. JohnsonPortisGoreA. Peterson BarberThanks!

A. PetersonAddaiBarber PortisLJGoreWillis

 

[Whiplash Inc.]

ADP

Addai

Portis

Gore

Barber

LJ

McGahee

 

[bucsbaby]

No love for Willis, eh? Do you guys see him as a (potential) top 10 RB this year still?

Certainly LJ will also be seeing 8 in the box all year, as will Gore and to a lesser extent Portis? Plus LJ is coming off of injury and has a suspect O-Line?

 

[munchkin]

No love for Willis, eh? Do you guys see him as a (potential) top 10 RB this year still?Certainly LJ will also be seeing 8 in the box all year, as will Gore and to a lesser extent Portis? Plus LJ is coming off of injury and has a suspect O-Line?

I am not an expert on McGhee but from some of the things I have read about him he has he talent but maybe not the willingness to be as good as he could be. All the backs you listed are very talented and much depends on the talent level around them. LJ has O-Line and QB issues. Addai gets dinged up and splits the load (while still beinig very productive), Gore has issues similar to LJ (dude has the heart though), Barber's never been a full time back; so if you really like McGhee go for it, at least you have the guy you want to root for.

 

[bucsbaby]

i'm not sold on mcgahee necessarily, which is why i posted this thread i'm just not sure, value-wise, it would be a good idea to try to move him plus some other talent/draft pick(s) to get someone only marginally better. i've seen some rankings that list mcgahee somewhere between 10-15 and portis around #6 so that is something i would pursue. but if mcgahee is going to be around 9 and portis around 7 i'm not sure if overpaying would be as good of an idea...that's where i'm at right now anyway thks!

 

[Dirty Weasel]

redraft or dynasty?

 

[mcd]

No love for Willis, eh? Do you guys see him as a (potential) top 10 RB this year still?Certainly LJ will also be seeing 8 in the box all year, as will Gore and to a lesser extent Portis? Plus LJ is coming off of injury and has a suspect O-Line?

Don't think Gore will be seeing 8 in the box much. Under Martz, there will be to many guys in coverage to focus a game plan on Gore. He should have room to run if Martz will let him.

 

[bucsbaby]

sorry, it is a 10-team IDP dynasty league

we keep our starting rosters (1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1K, 2LB, 2DL, 2DB, 1DB/DL/LB)

the reason i see gore facing 8 in the box all the time is because of the QB situation and lack of standout WRs (imo)