What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rank these WR's in a PPR (1 Viewer)

Man, you guys are tough on Fitz. I still think he is going to catch a ton of balls from Anderson. Fairly easy schedule and a freak of an athlete, plus no Boldin.

 
Team Canada said:
CalvinRoddyMarshallAustinFitz
Click to expand...
Last year I'd have Marshall on top of PPR; this year the bottom due to change of scenery and a new run first offense. Fitz's dropped due to huge downgrade at QB. Love Calvin, and I own him only, but in PPR I think Roddy has sustained production under his belt and Austin has a better QB and offense. Though the talen of Calvin is undeniable, I have him third here. JMO of course, but that's my gut right now. RoddyAustinCalvinFitzMarshall
 
calvin austin roddy in that order but all are really close by my count. moss and wayne are in this group too.

gaaap

fitz>marshall also very close.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Calvin

Fitz

Marshall

Roddy

Austin

This is based on talent, not necessarily points for this year. For points :

Calvin (freak with a talented and up and coming QB )

Fitz ( somebody has to catch 3,500 yards worth of passes )

Roddy ( lots of targets with a pretty qb )

Marshall ( running team, but is an elite wr that catches everything )

Austin ( good wr with a good qb. Their line worries me. Should be top 10 regardless )

 
calvin might be the best wr in the league. he is best of this grp. all our good but get megat if u can. 3 main leagues. got him in all 3.

 
I put Calvin and Roddy together in a tier -- by which I mean that I see no reason to feel confident enough in ranking one over the other. I'm very comfortable with both QB's, and both guys' roles in the offenses. So I'd just pick the one I liked better if I were you.

I put Fitz, Marshall, and Austin all in the next tier, which goes below the other two simply because for one reason or another, I need them all to prove it to me.

Anyway, if I had to pick two, it'd be Calvin and Roddy.

 
Happy Ragnarok said:
I put Calvin and Roddy together in a tier -- by which I mean that I see no reason to feel confident enough in ranking one over the other. I'm very comfortable with both QB's, and both guys' roles in the offenses. So I'd just pick the one I liked better if I were you.I put Fitz, Marshall, and Austin all in the next tier, which goes below the other two simply because for one reason or another, I need them all to prove it to me.Anyway, if I had to pick two, it'd be Calvin and Roddy.
Click to expand...
+1
 
Happy Ragnarok said:
I put Calvin and Roddy together in a tier -- by which I mean that I see no reason to feel confident enough in ranking one over the other. I'm very comfortable with both QB's, and both guys' roles in the offenses. So I'd just pick the one I liked better if I were you.

I put Fitz, Marshall, and Austin all in the next tier, which goes below the other two simply because for one reason or another, I need them all to prove it to me.

Anyway, if I had to pick two, it'd be Calvin and Roddy.
Click to expand...
really? What has Stafford done in the NFL so far?
 
zoonation said:
Happy Ragnarok said:
I put Calvin and Roddy together in a tier -- by which I mean that I see no reason to feel confident enough in ranking one over the other. I'm very comfortable with both QB's, and both guys' roles in the offenses. So I'd just pick the one I liked better if I were you.

I put Fitz, Marshall, and Austin all in the next tier, which goes below the other two simply because for one reason or another, I need them all to prove it to me.

Anyway, if I had to pick two, it'd be Calvin and Roddy.
Click to expand...
really? What has Stafford done in the NFL so far?
Click to expand...
passed the eyeball test and he will be fine. i would like his int's to drop though
 
degenerate said:
zoonation said:
Happy Ragnarok said:
I put Calvin and Roddy together in a tier -- by which I mean that I see no reason to feel confident enough in ranking one over the other. I'm very comfortable with both QB's, and both guys' roles in the offenses. So I'd just pick the one I liked better if I were you.

I put Fitz, Marshall, and Austin all in the next tier, which goes below the other two simply because for one reason or another, I need them all to prove it to me.

Anyway, if I had to pick two, it'd be Calvin and Roddy.
Click to expand...
really? What has Stafford done in the NFL so far?
Click to expand...
passed the eyeball test and he will be fine. i would like his int's to drop though
Click to expand...
I could give a crap about his INT's if I'm evaluating Calvin.Stafford seems quite happy to force the ball Calvin's way early, often, and in the red zone. He's doing well enough he's going to hold onto his job, and his contract makes that doubly so. I see no reason whatsoever to do anything with Calvin except like him more for as long as Stafford is at the helm. Will this be good for the Lions? I dunno. What's the difference, here?

If you trust Stafford to get Calvin the ball LESS than I do, by all means, ding him. :kicksrock:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think Calvin will be fine, but without elite QB play he won't finish top 3.

I've seen nothing from Stafford that makes me think he will be anywhere close to elite.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

T
The 3rd Tier of WRS
Replies
10
Views
704
Smack Tripper
S
Ramblin Wreck
Wide Receiver Depth Charts
Replies
21
Views
2K
Bri
B
BobbyLayne
Mid Rnd WRs: Godwin, Johnson, Kirk, McLaurin, Ridley
Replies
20
Views
2K
massraider
massraider

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top