Rate this blockbuster: J.Jones, J.McKinnon, D.Parker, L.Murray for A.Brown + A.Jeffery (1 Viewer)

[Saboo]

Who got the better of this deal?

Team A

Julio Jones, Jerick McKinnon, DeVante Parker, Latavius Murray

 Team B

Antonio Brown and Alshon Jeffery

Team A is loaded at RB + is concerned about Julio Jones lack of production to this point...Team B is loaded at wr and has very little at RB

Thanks for your opinion, will answer yours.

 

[jmble]

It's a tough call.

Take out McKinnon and Murray completely and just judge the other two.Jones and Brown are pretty equal in talent, but I like Jones' situation better right now.  I'd much rather have the guy getting the ball from Matt Ryan than from Roethlisberger right now.  Even if Sunday's game was an aberration for Big Ben, you still can't feel comfortable with where he is right now.

I think a healthy Parker and Jeffery are pretty much a wash talentwise.  Having said that, Parker is not healthy and Jeffery is playing for a much better team with a much better QB.  That part of the deal, I like Jeffery better.  

If Team A was desperate for running backs, then I like their trade better.  McKinnon looked like the guy on Monday night and Murray is pretty much just a handcuff at this point.

If the running backs were not an important part of the deal, the I like Team B better.  The slight upgrade (in my opinion) from Brown to Jones isn't as big as the drop off from Parker to Jeffery.

 

[BigBlue_RI]

I say Team B got the better. jmble basically said it all. I just don't like the Vikings RB situation at all.

My wk 6 start/sit: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/761469-cam-or-deshaun-funchess-or-fuller-in-wk-6/

 

[Saboo]

Thanks for the help. Could use as many opinions as possible.

 

[Saboo]

bump

 

[Skoo]

I would lean Team B as Antonio Brown is the most consistent player in fantasy football.

Julio is incredibly talented of course but is up and down week-to-week, and always ends up with injuries.

Also a note on Alshon, he's had crazy bad matchups to start the season.