Rb's - (1 Viewer)

[tytyty]

Here is the criteria. Rank this years top 20 based soley on the following:

The main RB on the team (not a whole lot of competition)

System they are in

Total Ydg

Injury History

Do not think Fantasy points, SOS, Oline, etc. - just off this raw data.

 

[Keys Myaths]

I'm confused on what you're asking.

You seem to be asking who will put up the best stats (system, total ydg), but you don't want us to think about fantasy value?

 

[tytyty]

I'm confused on what you're asking.You seem to be asking who will put up the best stats (system, total ydg), but you don't want us to think about fantasy value?

Right in a way. basically I am taking yardage and Td out. Just seeing who has the best situation. Basically if they opened up a new league and you had no history on these guys and didn't know lj was a stud and barlow was a dud, how would you rank the rb's without any prior knowledge based on the above criteria that you were privvy to.

 

[Real Man of Genius]

I'm confused on what you're asking.You seem to be asking who will put up the best stats (system, total ydg), but you don't want us to think about fantasy value?

Right in a way. basically I am taking yardage and Td out. Just seeing who has the best situation. Basically if they opened up a new league and you had no history on these guys and didn't know lj was a stud and barlow was a dud, how would you rank the rb's without any prior knowledge based on the above criteria that you were privvy to.

Why?

 

[Colin Dowling]

If I knew nothing about any of the RBs or their teams, I would rank "He Hate Me" first because he has a fun nickname.

 

[Keys Myaths]

If I knew nothing about any of the RBs or their teams, I would rank "He Hate Me" first because he has a fun nickname.

 

[by_the_sea_wannabe]

The main RB on the team (not a whole lot of competition)Total YdgInjury History

basically I am taking yardage and Td out. Just seeing who has the best situation. how would you rank the rb's without any prior knowledge based on the above criteria that you were privvy to.

 

[aposulli]

I'm confused on what you're asking.You seem to be asking who will put up the best stats (system, total ydg), but you don't want us to think about fantasy value?

Right in a way. basically I am taking yardage and Td out. Just seeing who has the best situation. Basically if they opened up a new league and you had no history on these guys and didn't know lj was a stud and barlow was a dud, how would you rank the rb's without any prior knowledge based on the above criteria that you were privvy to.

Why?

If "they" (commisioner?) opened a new league, then situation would not be a factor.If you want us to factor in situation + talent + injury history, that's basically asking: what is their fantasy value?If you were "opening a new league" and were to pick players based on pure abilites (talent, durability, experience), then the RBs should look something like:1. LT2. Shaun3. TikiAmong the others: Edge, LJ, McGahee and Portis

 

[Torew]

This is easy guys RICKY WILLIAMS!