Roddy White (1 Viewer)

[Badgers Fan]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

 

[Dr. Awesome]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

 

[Sabertooth]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

 

[omally]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting.

I don't think most people thought he was just an average player in a great situation. Some maybe according to a thread you read, but that doesn't qualify as "most" people. He was ranked in the top 10 in all preseason rankings, and last year was one of the most targeted players by a QB, and he has consistently put up great numbers the last 3 years. He was the one of the top 5 WR's taken in all of my leagues.

 

[eurotrashman]

 

[Black]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting.

I don't think most people thought he was just an average player in a great situation. Some maybe according to a thread you read, but that doesn't qualify as "most" people. He was ranked in the top 10 in all preseason rankings, and last year was one of the most targeted players by a QB, and he has consistently put up great numbers the last 3 years. He was the one of the top 5 WR's taken in all of my leagues.

Agree. Had him as a top 5, top 3 in terms of consistency. Has been my keeper for 2+ years. He didn't have alot of hype, but was quietly the Peyton Manning of WRs.

 

[fruity pebbles]

its funny though, atleast in my leagues, hes still not valued as elite.

 

[Ilov80s]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

I don't recall many saying he was average. I said that he didn't have elite ability, but he very polished and allows him to be as productive as any WR in football. I would compare him to Reggie Wayne. He doesn't have Calvin Johnson height, TO strength, or DeSean Jackson speed, but he knows how to get open and make plays within his offense.

 

[Ilov80s]

its funny though, atleast in my leagues, hes still not valued as elite.

Right now, anyone that doesn't understand White is elite is a moron. I am looking at stats for WRs right now and Roddy White has 34 more fantasy points than the next best WR- that is 25% more points. Insane.

 

[az_prof]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

I don't recall many saying he was average. I said that he didn't have elite ability, but he very polished and allows him to be as productive as any WR in football. I would compare him to Reggie Wayne. He doesn't have Calvin Johnson height, TO strength, or DeSean Jackson speed, but he knows how to get open and make plays within his offense.

Calvin Johnson doesn't have one thing White has: elite production. Frankly, I am tired of hearing how big and fast Johnson is. Let's see him put together two top 10 seasons in a row before we annoint the guy into the HOF.

 

[bigmarc27]

its funny though, atleast in my leagues, hes still not valued as elite.

Right now, anyone that doesn't understand White is elite is a moron. I am looking at stats for WRs right now and Roddy White has 34 more fantasy points than the next best WR- that is 25% more points. Insane.

To be 100% fair, the Falcons haven't had their bye week yet. I know 34 points is still a pretty large margin, but it's not as large with the extra game.Anyway, I think Roddy is a stud. He's got very good speed, very good hands, and he's one of the stronger WRs in the league.

 

[Ilov80s]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

I don't recall many saying he was average. I said that he didn't have elite ability, but he very polished and allows him to be as productive as any WR in football. I would compare him to Reggie Wayne. He doesn't have Calvin Johnson height, TO strength, or DeSean Jackson speed, but he knows how to get open and make plays within his offense.

Calvin Johnson doesn't have one thing White has: elite production. Frankly, I am tired of hearing how big and fast Johnson is. Let's see him put together two top 10 seasons in a row before we annoint the guy into the HOF.

Yes, this is exactly what I am saying. He does more with less compared to many of the WRs around the league.

 

[netnalp]

I've thought he was elite, those that didn't may have felt that he had a high floor but wouldn't have the huge point games like he did last week.

 

[GManiac]

I've thought he was elite, those that didn't may have felt that he had a high floor but wouldn't have the huge point games like he did last week.

The reason I think he's not Top tier elite is not because of this, but because if his situation happened to change, he probably would not have the success that those other, more gifted WR would. But as long as his situation is this good, he's probably middle tier elite. Meaning only AJ, Fitz, and in previous years Moss. I think Calvin could get to that level, but he hasnt yet. He has the potential too. If I was starting an organization though, i would much rather have any of those guys over Roddy.

 

[LittlePhatty]

Both this year and last year he was drafted as a Top 10 WR, usually around WR#8 or #9, and maybe as high as #5 or #6 this year. Next year he should be one of the Top 3 WRs to come off the board.

Seems like the typical arc for a rising player in fantasy football, where most owners make reactionary "after the fact" decisions.

 

[ty247]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

I don't recall many saying he was average. I said that he didn't have elite ability, but he very polished and allows him to be as productive as any WR in football. I would compare him to Reggie Wayne. He doesn't have Calvin Johnson height, TO strength, or DeSean Jackson speed, but he knows how to get open and make plays within his offense.

Calvin Johnson doesn't have one thing White has: elite production. Frankly, I am tired of hearing how big and fast Johnson is. Let's see him put together two top 10 seasons in a row before we annoint the guy into the HOF.

Something else Calvin doesn't have? How about an elite, consistent QB and a monster running game to keep defenses honest? It took Roddy 4 years to put up a season even close to what Calvin put up in year 2.. let's give the guy a little credit now.I've got Roddy in 3 leagues and Calvin in 1.. so non-biased here.. but Calvin's not exactly having a terrible year at the moment either

 

[fruity pebbles]

I've thought he was elite, those that didn't may have felt that he had a high floor but wouldn't have the huge point games like he did last week.

The reason I think he's not Top tier elite is not because of this, but because if his situation happened to change, he probably would not have the success that those other, more gifted WR would. But as long as his situation is this good, he's probably middle tier elite. Meaning only AJ, Fitz, and in previous years Moss. I think Calvin could get to that level, but he hasnt yet. He has the potential too. If I was starting an organization though, i would much rather have any of those guys over Roddy.

How has Fitz's success been lately in a less than ideal situation?

 

[meatwad1]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

I was always under the impression that White was considered top 5. I sure know that I spent a 2nd rounder on him, and he went in the 2nd in another draft I had. Maybe this topic should be about all the folks that are finally coming around on Hakeem Nicks.

 

[GManiac]

I've thought he was elite, those that didn't may have felt that he had a high floor but wouldn't have the huge point games like he did last week.

The reason I think he's not Top tier elite is not because of this, but because if his situation happened to change, he probably would not have the success that those other, more gifted WR would. But as long as his situation is this good, he's probably middle tier elite. Meaning only AJ, Fitz, and in previous years Moss. I think Calvin could get to that level, but he hasnt yet. He has the potential too. If I was starting an organization though, i would much rather have any of those guys over Roddy.

How has Fitz's success been lately in a less than ideal situation?

depends, in my non ppr league, all but 1 week has given me adequate points. He's still giving me about 8 points per game, which I expect to rise as he's had a couple of poor games. For a WR on a bad team, with no QB and well, a mess , I thnk he has done about what you could expect. As long as he throws a few big games in during the season, his avg should level out. And i know its hypothetical, but if you stuck Fitz in Atlanta in place of Roddy, I think his numbers would be astronomical. like 5 x 10 to the 23rd power Yards.

 

[emge]

I think ppl have changed their mind now, and he's on most ppl minds as a top receiver. Someone offered me Hightower and Deion Branch for him.

My guess, he's getting ready to dump both players and wanted to see if I would want to get rid of Roddy White... stupid, considering I dropped Hightower in week 4

 

[cmv5]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

I don't recall many saying he was average. I said that he didn't have elite ability, but he very polished and allows him to be as productive as any WR in football. I would compare him to Reggie Wayne. He doesn't have Calvin Johnson height, TO strength, or DeSean Jackson speed, but he knows how to get open and make plays within his offense.

Calvin Johnson doesn't have one thing White has: elite production. Frankly, I am tired of hearing how big and fast Johnson is. Let's see him put together two top 10 seasons in a row before we annoint the guy into the HOF.

Yes, let's not use speculation at all in fantasy football. Let's rely on strictly previous production to expect what a receiver is worth. What people should do is look at a similar situation here. You have two receivers in Roddy White and Calvin Johnson who have managed to put up good numbers without elite quarterbacks. Now that White has a reliable QB that he has chemistry with throwing him the ball, he has taken it to the next level. If Stafford can remain healthy, the same thing will happen with Calvin Johnson. Considering the numbers Calvin Johnson has put up so far in his career, especially compared to everyone's darling, Andre Johnson, I don't get the hate.

 

[coolnerd]

Roddy White is 6'0 210-215 lbs 4.4 guy who drafted in the first round. He is a well-above average athlete and has football skills. No sure where the idea that he is not that "talented" came from.

 

[Mainevent]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...&p=12199516See Post #1.

:linkedup:

 

[netnalp]

I've thought he was elite, those that didn't may have felt that he had a high floor but wouldn't have the huge point games like he did last week.

The reason I think he's not Top tier elite is not because of this, but because if his situation happened to change, he probably would not have the success that those other, more gifted WR would. But as long as his situation is this good, he's probably middle tier elite. Meaning only AJ, Fitz, and in previous years Moss. I think Calvin could get to that level, but he hasnt yet. He has the potential too. If I was starting an organization though, i would much rather have any of those guys over Roddy.

Could be the separation between real life elite and FF elite. In FF he's top tier, but in real life he doesn't have the package of AJ, FItz & Moss. There were also many people putting Miles Austin in the top 3, which was too high. People probably look at the Falcons and think, they're just a running team or Gonzo steals catches. I had it AJ, then Roddy. I stayed away from Fitz due to the QB situation and I didn't think Brady was going to be close to the TD record.

 

[Dr. Awesome]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

I did a quick search for Roddy White and didn't see it. But it's there. I remember several people saying him finishing as the #1 wr this year was their gutsy call of 2010.ETA I see mainevent found one of the links.

 

[fruity pebbles]

Roddy White is 6'0 210-215 lbs 4.4 guy who drafted in the first round. He is a well-above average athlete and has football skills. No sure where the idea that he is not that "talented" came from.

i think its cause it took him a couple years. the other guys ahead of him seemed to hit the ground running.

 

[GManiac]

Roddy White is 6'0 210-215 lbs 4.4 guy who drafted in the first round. He is a well-above average athlete and has football skills. No sure where the idea that he is not that "talented" came from.

Well he's definitely talented. He's just not as talented as other guys. But he has made himself more reliable than most.

 

[netnalp]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

I did a quick search for Roddy White and didn't see it. But it's there. I remember several people saying him finishing as the #1 wr this year was their gutsy call of 2010.ETA I see mainevent found one of the links.

A good number had him top 2 or 3 as well. But most probably had him top 7 yet had Miles Austin top 3.

 

[Dr. Awesome]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

I did a quick search for Roddy White and didn't see it. But it's there. I remember several people saying him finishing as the #1 wr this year was their gutsy call of 2010.ETA I see mainevent found one of the links.

A good number had him top 2 or 3 as well. But most probably had him top 7 yet had Austin Miles top 3.

I had Roddy as my #4. Miles as my #1 (which could still easily happen).

 

[abe froman]

Theres only 1 guy Id rather have in a PPR than White and thats AJ. They guys is young, no real health concerns as of yet, catches 100balls..Ill take his consistency over guys like Moss, CJ, Miles all day who tend to have bigger peaks and valleys not to mention lower reception totals..

 

[GManiac]

I think it makes the most sense from a Dynasty perspective. Currently, if I was looking at winning within the next 3 years.

I would want in order AJ, Austin, White, Wayne.

If I was looking at 4 years and beyond. I would probably want

AJ, Calvin, Fitz, Austin

Those guys have the potential to outproduce Roddy if their situations become as good as his. Higher upside and longer upside due to talent level. Where if anything changed for Roddy, he would drop down a bit similar to how Fitz has now, but I think more so. Maybe on a Greg Jennings level.

 

[fruity pebbles]

I think it makes the most sense from a Dynasty perspective. Currently, if I was looking at winning within the next 3 years.I would want in order AJ, Austin, White, Wayne.If I was looking at 4 years and beyond. I would probably want AJ, Calvin, Fitz, Austin Those guys have the potential to outproduce Roddy if their situations become as good as his. Higher upside and longer upside due to talent level. Where if anything changed for Roddy, he would drop down a bit similar to how Fitz has now, but I think more so. Maybe on a Greg Jennings level.

AJ and Austin are already in situations as good as him. Roddy signed a 6 year year last season, not sure why things would change for the negative unless he gets hurt.

 

[Instinctive]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

Here ya go:

Personally I have Fitz as the #3 behind Andre and Roddy White. White has been one of the best for a long time now, and doesn't look to slow down anytime soon. Especially with an improving QB and team around him, I think he could finish at the top for the next 6 or 7 years.

 

[Badgers Fan]

I'm not saying anyone here didn't have him ranked top 10. i had him #4 pre season, and i know alot of people thought highly of him. However not many he was more than above average, or good, just a good player in a great situation. A lot of you bought into him from a fantasy perspective, but weren't totally sold on him as a real football player. Many were harping on his low catch to target percentage (it was around 55% of the top of my head). All I'm saying is that I think he needs to be recognized as an elite football player, real and fantasy. Pre-season the buzz was that he was good or above average player in a great situation, which did lead to a lot of people ranking him as a middle to low end wr1. I'm just saying it now appears he is an elite player, in a great situation, which should lead to top notch wr1 numbers.

 

[Da Guru]

its funny though, atleast in my leagues, hes still not valued as elite.

The teams that have Roddy value him as elite. That is really all that matters.

 

[Jayrod]

I had him ranked at #5 in PPR to start the season and was lucky to get him at 3.10 in a 10 teamer as the 7th WR off the board. I also selected him in the subsciber contest, but that was mostly due to his price being lower then the guys I had ranked around him.

I was high on him, but wouldn't have picked him in the top 3 WR's pre-season.

 

[az_prof]

I think it makes the most sense from a Dynasty perspective. Currently, if I was looking at winning within the next 3 years.I would want in order AJ, Austin, White, Wayne.If I was looking at 4 years and beyond. I would probably want AJ, Calvin, Fitz, Austin Those guys have the potential to outproduce Roddy if their situations become as good as his. Higher upside and longer upside due to talent level. Where if anything changed for Roddy, he would drop down a bit similar to how Fitz has now, but I think more so. Maybe on a Greg Jennings level.

This makes no sense. Greg Jennings has Aaron Rodgers throwing the rock to him and he is the WR1 on his team right now, and even so he is no better than a WR3. Has he ever had 1 year as good as White's last three? And how is are AJ andAustin's situations worse than his now? They all have good QBs and offenses--some would say better. Yet they are being out produced by him. And as for Calvin, when he can put together two good season in a row wake me up.

 

[abe froman]

? the people that do not recognize Roddy as elite by now are idiots, period. And how is his situation any worse than DAL?? Austin is behind him in all rankings. people need to wake up already.

 

[T with T]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

for redraft ppr RODDY WHITE is number 1 wr by far right now... I have heard guys say he is 2nd tier wr and that is all bs... White is on pace for 123 catches 1700 yards and 11.4 tds... he is first in rec, targets and yards he is a beast....

 

[T with T]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

yes peeps had him top 7-9 at best on the rankings I had never 1... I had him top 3 coming into season and now he is 1

 

[T with T]

I've thought he was elite, those that didn't may have felt that he had a high floor but wouldn't have the huge point games like he did last week.

The reason I think he's not Top tier elite is not because of this, but because if his situation happened to change, he probably would not have the success that those other, more gifted WR would. But as long as his situation is this good, he's probably middle tier elite. Meaning only AJ, Fitz, and in previous years Moss. I think Calvin could get to that level, but he hasnt yet. He has the potential too. If I was starting an organization though, i would much rather have any of those guys over Roddy.

your fooling yourself bud and to the guy saying he doesn't have speed of djax strength of TO u are naming some of the best at each category RODDY is extremely athletic, great hands, very strong, very fast and goes over middle and is targeted alot.. makes one handed catches and is just a jonny on the spot pro bowl stud and is def elite... if he isn't elite i dont know what is

 

[T with T]

Roddy White is 6'0 210-215 lbs 4.4 guy who drafted in the first round. He is a well-above average athlete and has football skills. No sure where the idea that he is not that "talented" came from.

very Roddy can do back flips and is incredibly amazing and strong/fast and just great hands and plays the position so naturally... I dont think Fitzgerald would put up as good numbers as Roddy even if u put him in ATL>> thats BS WHITE is top dawg.

 

[T with T]

WTH are you talking about? Loads of folk loved this kid coming into the season. Hell, lots of sharks/hawks/and other barnyard animals touted him as the #1 wr by the end of this season.

Really? Link up us on these #1 predictions.

I did a quick search for Roddy White and didn't see it. But it's there. I remember several people saying him finishing as the #1 wr this year was their gutsy call of 2010.ETA I see mainevent found one of the links.

A good number had him top 2 or 3 as well. But most probably had him top 7 yet had Austin Miles top 3.

Miles Austin dope.... and as for the people saying he is above avg on a great sit wake up he is amazing talent in a great situation thats all

 

[telfo]

It amazes me that people put guys like Miles Austin in their top 5 WR after less than a full season of being good. Roddy White is now having his 4th great year in a row(should easily be career highs) and a lot of people dont have him as a top 5 WR by now. Of course a lot of this is because the Falcons dont have Brett Favre or play in the NFC East

 

[Northbound Train]

Coming into this season, while looking at the pre-season player spotlight on him, most people thought he was just an above average player in a great situation, due to all the targets he was getting. Concerns about double teams rolled in the second Jenkins got hurt. I think its time to recognize that, skill wise he is a top tiered receiver. I'm not sure how high, but he is DESTROYING double teams. Matt Ryan's growth helps a lot, obviously. One would believe that at some point the team does something to get the other receivers involved more so that opposing teams don't just put the whole team on him. I'm sure over the bye week they'll do something. However, this is not just a trend, for 7 straight games he has not had below 5 catches or 69 yards. He doesn't face any elite pass defenses the rest of the way. He seems primed to finish the year at #1. No one really talks about him, so I decided too, because he sure deserves some credit.

I don't recall many saying he was average. I said that he didn't have elite ability, but he very polished and allows him to be as productive as any WR in football. I would compare him to Reggie Wayne. He doesn't have Calvin Johnson height, TO strength, or DeSean Jackson speed, but he knows how to get open and make plays within his offense.

Calvin Johnson doesn't have one thing White has: elite production. Frankly, I am tired of hearing how big and fast Johnson is. Let's see him put together two top 10 seasons in a row before we annoint the guy into the HOF.

All he mentioned here was Calvin's height ....Bitter are we

 

[Dr. Awesome]

This is getting ridiculous. Honestly, who doesn't have him in their top 5? Maybe one or two nutjobs? Fantasy wise, he's there easily. Real life, I'd put him there but I won't mock another who disagrees as there are loads of elite talents right now:

Fitzgerald

AJ

Austin

White

Calvin

Marshall

DeSean

Wayne

TO

And loads more.

 

[Bad_Mo]

This is getting ridiculous. Honestly, who doesn't have him in their top 5? Maybe one or two nutjobs? Fantasy wise, he's there easily. Real life, I'd put him there but I won't mock another who disagrees as there are loads of elite talents right now: FitzgeraldAJAustinWhiteCalvinMarshallDeSeanWayneTOAnd loads more.

Glad that Roddy fell to me as the #7 WR drafted (14-teamer). I chose him over Fitzgerald and am very glad.

 

[ClownDogs]

This is getting ridiculous. Honestly, who doesn't have him in their top 5? Maybe one or two nutjobs? Fantasy wise, he's there easily. Real life, I'd put him there but I won't mock another who disagrees as there are loads of elite talents right now: FitzgeraldAJAustinWhiteCalvinMarshallDeSeanWayneTOAnd loads more.

Someone made a good point, WHY is austin ahead of him after exactly ONE good year? Roddy had more catches, <200 less yards than Austin AND did it for THREE consecutive years.I just don't get the Austin love at all, not saying he isn't good, but to put him top 3 AHEAD of Roddy?