Rookie updates (1 Viewer)

[Bracie Smathers]

Nice article on BR that ranks rookies at the quarter mark of the season.

Sure to change as young guys get worked in and return from injury so this is based on play to date.

Not just defenders but all rookies.

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2736478-nfl1000-rookie-rankings-at-the-seasons-quarter-mark

NFL1000: Rookie Rankings at the Season's Quarter Mark

NFL1000 SCOUTSOCTOBER 4, 2017

 

[Bronco Billy]

Any rookie rankings at the quarter mark that don’t have Hunt listed as #1 doesn’t have a whole lot of credibility IMO.

 

[Bronco Billy]

OJ Howard and his 4 catches make the list.  Jarrad Davis doesn’t.  Okay

 

[Pipes]

Article has Beckwith 5 in the outside LB category and doesn't even mention him in the LB analysis other than the comment after Bowser the LB's are easy to forget.  His production has been way better than Riley and Anzalone.

 

[Bracie Smathers]

Anyone who even attempts to rank every single rookie on offense and defense after only a quarter of the season should be praised for the effort..

I applaud the work but if you think you are better then come up with your own rankings of every single rookie at the half way point. 

I like to see any sort of in-season updates on rookies but I've never seen an attempt to rank every single rookie at the quarter mark.

 

[Bronco Billy]

I applaud the work but if you think you are better then come up with your own rankings of every single rookie at the half way point. 

So people on a message board are not allowed to be critical of a list that has some incredibly overt questionable rankings unless they create a list of their own?

Are you new to this message board thing?  Just because somebody posts a list does not by that act automatically make it a good list or a good effort.  The list you posted is a perfect case in point.

.

 

[Bracie Smathers]

So people on a message board are not allowed to be critical of a list that has some incredibly overt questionable rankings unless they create a list of their own?

Are you new to this message board thing?  Just because somebody posts a list does not by that act automatically make it a good list or a good effort.  The list you posted is a perfect case in point.

.

I am  not new and expected this reply by you and was positive you lacked the brains and guts to create your own list.

 

[Bronco Billy]

I am  not new and expected this reply by you and was positive you lacked the brains and guts to create your own list.

Thanks. Have a great day.

 

[Flyman75]

I am  not new and expected this reply by you and was positive you lacked the brains and guts to create your own list.

Wow...really no need for that.