Should I accept this trade? (1 Viewer)

[sassytaco23]

Lost David Johnson (put him on my IR spot) and Allen Robinson. Our league is 10 man, half PPR, 5 PATD, with bonuses for big yardage games and long TDs. I was offered 3 trades from the same guy, if I accept any, I'm leaning towards this one where I get Mike Evans. Would you guys accept this?

I receive: Mike Evans, Ertz or Kelce, Jordan Howard, Russell Wilson

I trade: Christian McCaffrey, Gronk, Fitzgerald, Crowder

My current roster:

QB- Stafford

RBs: Fournette, McCaffrey, Gore, Riddick, Ellington

WRs: Fitzgerald, Diggs, Crowder, Tyrell Williams, Kenny Golladay, Corey Coleman

TE: Gronk

He originally wanted Golladay (instead of Fitzgerald) and would give me Keenan Allen (instead of Mike Evans). That would give me a better flex, but I don't love it.

Thoughts?

 

[oddsbodkins]

I think you slightly upgrade at RB but you get a big bump at WR. Plus, PPR... You lose a bit at TE but Kelce is a fine replacement. I'd do it.

 

[beerbuff]

Take it as is with Kelce. Do not take the Keenan Allen or Ertz trade, Keenan is to injury prone to trust.

 

[Hartliner]

I agree to take it with Kelce

Please leave an opinion

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/760361-dalvin-cookty-hilton-for-baldwinpowell-or-carson/

 

[ffwebster]

nice trade as listed, I think

 

[irchrisr]

Easy trade, take it!

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/760371-tyrod-taylor-vs-hogan/

 

[Gally]

I assume this is not dynasty and just a redraft.  That being the case this is a really easy accept.

 

[Spectrum]

Take it. Your starting lineup is much better.

You get the best value in Evans. Kelce and Gronk could be even or Kelce wins if Gronk gets hurt. Jordan Howard, R. Wilson vs McCaffrey, Fitz, Crowder. Easy. You arguably upgrade at QB (arguable but I'll still take R. Wilson rest of year) and your starting WR's are Evans and Diggs. You get a better RB (I'll take chances with Howard this year over McCaffrey).

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/760370-drop-j-charles-for-james-white-or-corey-davis/

 

[Blagar3lsu]

Lost David Johnson (put him on my IR spot) and Allen Robinson. Our league is 10 man, half PPR, 5 PATD, with bonuses for big yardage games and long TDs. I was offered 3 trades from the same guy, if I accept any, I'm leaning towards this one where I get Mike Evans. Would you guys accept this?

I receive: Mike Evans, Ertz or Kelce, Jordan Howard, Russell Wilson

I trade: Christian McCaffrey, Gronk, Fitzgerald, Crowder

My current roster:

QB- Stafford

RBs: Fournette, McCaffrey, Gore, Riddick, Ellington

WRs: Fitzgerald, Diggs, Crowder, Tyrell Williams, Kenny Golladay, Corey Coleman

TE: Gronk

He originally wanted Golladay (instead of Fitzgerald) and would give me Keenan Allen (instead of Mike Evans). That would give me a better flex, but I don't love it.

Thoughts?

All dam day!  I think now is the time to sell high on Gronk.  It's possibly slight down grade but you're keeping an elite TE.  Your upping to an elite tier 1 WR from tier 2 or 3 in fitzi who's QB looked like he may be done last week.

Carolina didn't look natural with mccaffery last week.  Yes, cohen looked good but he is 5'6, 160.  J Howard is the bell cow back on what may be a sub par team, but has a GREAT o line.  He will get all goal line touches.

 

[motoclube]

I would accept this trade with Kelce.