Should i trade Zambrano,McClouth and get Verlander and Beltran? (1 Viewer)

[wtu311]

My Team

1B- C.Jackson,Votto

2B- B. Phillips

SS-Lugo, Barmes

3B-Wright,Longoria

Util Ortiz

Nomar Garciaparra

OF

Burrell,Nady,McClouth,Rios,Melky Cabrera,Victorino

P

Zambrano,Hamels,Penny,Weaver,Greinke,Cabrera,Danks,Lackey

RP

Jenks,Isringhausen,Valverde,Fuentes

 

[valence]

no

 

[wtu311]

no

What about getting C.Hart back instead of Beltran?

 

[shadyridr]

Hell ####in yeah. Beltran > Hart

 

[MrPhoenix]

I love this deal for you.

Verlander > Zambrano (slightly)

Beltran >>>>>>>> McLouth

 

[Clifton]

Take it before he comes to his senses.

 

[shadyridr]

I love this deal for you.Verlander > Zambrano (slightly)Beltran >>>>>>>> McLouth

I think the other people in this thread are slightly nuts

 

[TitusIII]

I'd take Z over Verlander for this season, but unless McClouth found the best juice on earth, I'd make the deal...

 

[pollardsvision]

absolutely, you do that.

 

[boom king]

I'd take Z over Verlander for this season, but unless McClouth found the best juice on earth, I'd make the deal...

i agree with this feller.... beltran is a huge upgrade over mcclouth. way bigger than the drop is from Z to V

 

[wtu311]

damn the guy reconsidered he is now offering Torrie Hunter its a 3 year keeper in year 1

Its tempting should i do this or counter with C. Hart?

Thanks for the responses!

 

[Your Mother]

Hells yeah.