Should I trade (1 Viewer)

[jmble]

In my non-ppr standard scoring league, I've been asked if I would give up one of my running backs for Goff.  Not sure whether it's worth it based on the rest of my team.

Start 1 QB / 2 RB / 3 WR / 1 TE / 1 Flex

My team - QB - Cousins, Alex Smith           RB - Bell, Elliott, Montgomery, Ingram, Martin, Cohen

                 WR - DeSean Jackson, Hilton, Thielen, Crabtree, Moncrief     TE - Fleener, Cousins

His team - QB - Rodgers, Goff, Bortles, Luck          RB - Hunt, Smallwood, Javorious Allen, Alex Collins, Aaron Jones

                 WR - Beckham, DeVante Parker, Marqise Lee, J Kearse, E Sanders, P Richardson      TE - Witten

Is Goff an upgrade?  He's been playing well, but is he that much better than Cousins or Smith?  He's averaged 24.9 ppg vs Cousins 24.0 and Smith  at 30.6 ppg.  Smith is ahead so far this year, but history tells me he will likely not score that high all season.

Bottom line, is trading for Goff worth it to make a 3-1 team who's been hurt by injuries stronger?

 

[Shlune]

i like cousins and smith over goff so id say no.........he needs RB help and ur stacked at RB so I understand him looking to trade with you, but I feel you have the upperhand to poach a package for Rodgers or Park/Sanders.....doesnt hurt to try.......the possible trade really isnt about goff, its about the other guy needing a RB and I feel u would be giving him one for nothing if you only got goff in return

 

[Gally]

I would look more at working a deal for a WR.  I think you are fine at QB and Goff wouldn't really be any meaningful upgrade if he is an upgrade at all.  I would go after Parker.  Offer up his choice of Ingram or Cohen for Parker and see what he says.   

 

[beerbuff]

Nope, stay with what you have.

 

[travdogg]

I would look more at working a deal for a WR.  I think you are fine at QB and Goff wouldn't really be any meaningful upgrade if he is an upgrade at all.  I would go after Parker.  Offer up his choice of Ingram or Cohen for Parker and see what he says.   

I agree with this, and would also consider Sanders at WR, if Parker is too much.

 

[themeistersinger]

Healthy running backs are the coin of the realm in fantasy.  You've got a good stable.  I would not trade any of them for less than a top-6 QB.

I would offer a 2-for-1 to try to get Beckham.  Any of Montgomery or Ingram or Martin or Cohen plus any of your WR's for Beckham.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/761333-palmer-newton-or-roethlisberger-whir/