Maclin is still meh on balls he has to compete for for the most part, lacks my ball mentality. just not a physical guy when it comes time to bang for the ball in the air. does have the speed to get free in Chip O. Maclin is closer than Matthews, i'll say thatI bolded the part in Sig's post where he states his definition of an NFL WR1 (not FFL). So by his definition not every team has a true #1WR. However, I don't agree that Maclin lacks either of those 2 requirements. Not a deep threat guy? In his first year as the Eagles' #1 he's averaging over 17 yds per reception and tied for 2nd in the league 5 plays of 40+.Agreed. Watkins/Beckham/Benjamin/Allen/Evans/Floyd are all projections right now. If your argument against Maclin is let's see him do it for more than one season, than I would present the same argument for the guys I just listed.Sort of ridiculous not to have Maclin in that group. PFF has Maclin as the #5 WR over all right now. ZERO Drops, 2nd in the league in TDs, 12th in receptions, 7th in targets, 8th in yards, 8th in YAC...I dont think there are 31 #1 WRs in the NFLCan you name 31 other NFL #1 WR's please.no no, celek is budding superstar too.https://twitter.com/MikeClayNFL/status/532055173477044224
Chip adamant not to read too much into Matthews' big game. Gameplan was to focus on slot/inside. Explains Celek too.
8:56pm - 10 Nov 14
matthews is going to be a fine NFL WR. I'll admit that I underestimated the quality of the fit in this role in philly, could bloat his numbers too (look at Maclin's #s right now. Is anyone arguing that he is truly an elite talent?). He's still not an NFL #1 WR and not a WR who is going to shake good man coverage or win tough balls in the air consistently.
a "#1 WR" is one with a diverse skillset who can be everything from a deep threat to a guy who can make the tough catch in traffic to convert the 3rd and 7. ability to win in multiple ways is the essence.
NFL WR1s (off the top of my head)
Sammy Watkins
Andre Johnson? (definitely used to be/debatable now, DeAndre Hopkins might get there with more consistency)
Antonio Brown
Josh Gordon? (we'll see)
AJ Green
Demaryius Thomas
Keenan Allen (was on track last year we'll see)
Dez Bryant
Pierre Garcon (not being used as one right now)
Odell Beckham
Jordy Nelson
Alshon Jeffery
Brandon Marshall
Calvin Johnson
Kelvin Benjamin (projects as one with consistency a la Braylon Edwards)
Julio Jones/Roddy White
Mike Evans/Vincent Jackson
Larry Fitzgerald/Michael Floyd (projects as one but in a slump right now)
Tough possession yards for a 1st down? His 1st down % is 68.8. Compare those numbers to Antonio Brown (a true #1 on Sig's list) has 3 plays of 40+ (13.5 yds/rec) and a 1st down % of 63.3. D. Thomas? 5 receptions of 40+ (15.4 yds/rec) and 61.5%. Dez? Averaging 14.2 with 4 & 64.3.
Maclin compares favorably imho.