Your judging Dayne off his NFL career. I am making an assumption here, but i assume you didn't watch Dayne much if at all in college.
In college he had a very nice burst and had many nice sized runs. LenDale didn't run the 40 at the combine, did he? I would bet Dayne's 40 was faster.
Comparing him to Bettis is even weaker than to Dayne. Bettis was one of the few big backs who had solid success, there are handfulls of others who didn't.
I never said LenDale is a slug, but he is fat and unmotivated. I think he has talent, not as much as Dayne had, but enough where if he actually took football seriously and wasn't a headcase he could have some decent success.
Don't confuse me comparing him to Dayne as a bad thing, Dayne was a highly talented RB who just couldn't convert to the NFL game.
Dayne was without a doubt a better college RB then White, maybe White's game will translate better to the NFL, but i actually think he'll be lucky to have the kind of career Dayne's had so far.
Dayne always looked slow to me and I always said that he would be a bust. I disagree about their 40 times. LenDale gets caught from behind quite often, but he has very good acceleration through the hole. He plays like a 4.5 guy for the first 20-30 yards. My point about Bettis wasn't to compare his playing style to White's, but rather to show that one back (White) is the butt of constant jokes for being overweight whereas the other back (Bettis) never gets the same treatment despite being an even bigger tub of lard.
I never said LenDale is a slug, but he is fat and unmotivated. I think he has talent, not as much as Dayne had, but enough where if he actually took football seriously and wasn't a headcase he could have some decent success.
You're just jumping to conclusions here. All of the evidence suggesting that LenDale is "a headcase" and doesn't "take football seriously" is circumstantial. It's not like we're talking about Pacman Jones here. The guy's record is spotless. And he always played hard in college in spite of whatever shortcomings in conditioning he may have had. Is there some legitimate cause for concern? Sure. The fact that Tennessee pursued Turner, drafted Henry, and signed Brown doesn't indicate a lot of faith in White. Nevertheless, it's too early to write him off.
And again, calling him a "slug" while giving guys like Bettis a pass is inconsistent. Some body types don't allow for a chiseled statue of David physique. LenDale will always have some extra pounds. As I mentioned earlier, he played the Rose Bowl at 250 pounds and was dominant enough to have lots of people on these very boards saying he looked better than Reggie Bush. And now many of those same people are ripping him constantly.
Personally, I'm not that quick to do a full 180 on a guy who dominated in college and has a chance to become a starter in the NFL. If he flops this season, then I'll reconsider my stance.