Hard to tell whether Jennings's injuries are just short-term bad luck, or something that will depress his numbers all year. I've seen enough of Jones to know he's no more than a bye/injury fill in, as he'll get his 45/600/5 again this year.Cobb, on the other hand, is going to be in the 70-80 catch range this year. Obviously it's not so bold to claim that after 9 catches in Week 1, but he's on waivers in tons of leagues. He has to be one of the top claims. I would take him over Ogletree or Hill.
I think you're reading this situation wrong re James Jones. Donald Driver is nothing more than injury security at this point in his career and is being phased out. This puts roughly 400/5 on the table for the other receivers. Based on week 1 snap counts it looks like James Jones may stand to benefit from this. 600/5 is his floor. Given the increase in snap counts he should be able to outproduce his past years production. Also, all the training camp and preseason reports were very positive on Jones. He apparently is in the best shape of his career and has looked better than in years past. His lack of dropped passes was specifically mentioned in this article:
http://www.jsonline.com/sports/packers/nelson-shines-in-camp-ac6de4u-165372066.htmlJones was on the field more than Cobb. He'll have the benefit of being the third or fourth guy accounted for by the defense. In this offense, you just never know... it could be his year. It was Jordy's last year. Defenses will adjust accordingly. Rodgers is going to take what the defense gives him. Could it be Cobb's year? Sure. My point is I like Jones to have an uptick in production compared to years past. How much remains to be seen.
Something is going on here with James Jones. I'd grab him as quickly as possible. Huge negativity around him by fantasy players used to Jones' one great game then nothing pattern for the last 5 years makes him cheap. He wasn't picked up on waivers in my league and sounds like he is on the WW in quite a few others. So the price is right. On the other hand, apparently he is in the best shape of his life, is catching the ball better (hands not body), had a great first game and Jennnings is dinged up. What is most interesting though is why the hell did Jennings play in the slot last week? Did Jones take the starting outside WR position and nobody realized it? The outside receiver position is a big, big fantasy position in this offense and if the change is permanent, 4 for 86 and 1td may not be an abberation. I think he should be on every roster right now. In the very short term he has a chance to put WR 1 or 2 numbers if Jennings is out tonight (which sounds likely) and in the long run, there is real potential that he could be in line for a big, big uptick in production all season long. Cobb is the sexy pick-up but James Jones may be the guy to get.