Trade advice needed - Sheets for Roberts/Utley (1 Viewer)

[Texican]

Someone in my league offered me his B. Roberts for my Sheets. He also has Utley, so I am not sure if I should take it, counter it, or what.

My current second basemen are Uggla and Sanchez.

My roster:

C- Pierzynski

1B - Hafner

2B - Uggla

3B - Chipper

SS - Rollins

UTIL - D.Lee

OF - Rios

OF - Sheffield

OF - Hawpe

BN - Griffey

BN - Ibanez

BN - Adam LaRoche

BN - F.Sanchez

BN - McLouth

SP - J.Santana

SP - B.Sheets

SP - Carmona

SP - Bedard

SP - R.Johnson

SP - T.Hudson

RP - Capps

RP - Soria

RP - Sherrill

RP - Lidge

RP - Lyon

RP - Heilman

RP - Delcarmen

RP - Foulke

 

[Clifton]

I'd take it in a flash.

 

[Limp Ditka]

I'd take it in a flash.

I would too and I'd be instantly trying to move Uggla

 

[shadyridr]

Id take Roberts for Sheets no doubt. In order to get Utley, you'd have to give up Bedard PLUS a hitter

 

[avoiding injuries]

Sheets isn't injured YET, so it's a good time to deal. Roberts has a great chance of landing on a better offense sometime this year that should increase his numbers.

 

[thehornet]

absolutely do not give up sheets for roberts. sheets is a top5 pitcher if healthy.

 

[shadyridr]

absolutely do not give up sheets for roberts. sheets is a top5 pitcher if healthy.

IFYP2nd of all, top 5 pitchers usually get taken in the 4th rd. That's still AFTER Roberts is usually gone.

 

[Clifton]

absolutely do not give up sheets for roberts. sheets is a top5 pitcher if healthy.

I disagree. Not anymore hes not and IF he's healthy is a big question mark. He's got pitching firepower in his roster and can trade Uggla for another pitcher.

 

[Clifton]

God the guy's got Bedard Santana and Carmona and your blathering about Sheets for Roberts? C'mon.

You could use a solid closer

 

[Texican]

Thanks guys. I went ahead and accepted it.