Trade Advice (1 Viewer)

[ianfitzy]

I am in a H2H points 1st year keeper where we can keep 4 players. Is this offering to much for Matt Holliday or is it a fair offer?

I am offering BJ Upton and Josh Johnson for Holliday.

Will Upton rebound and make me regret offering this?

The league takes -.5 for Ks, everything else is standard.

 

[Widbil83]

I personally think Upton with rebound and took him in my big money league recently. I wouldn't do it because I would feel I was giving up too much. Here's the latest on Upton-

Mar 26 CF B.J. Upton finally realizes his potential and approaches the .300-30-30 numbers long forecast for him to go along with his Gold Glove caliber defense. After saying all of last year Upton was fine, the Rays now acknowledge he was never 100 percent following Nov. 2008 left shoulder surgery. He has meshed well with new hitting coach Derek Shelton and the spring returns are good as he shows improved mechanics and more pop in his bat.

What's not to love?

 

[Finless]

Don't do it. If you want a big bat in a points league Holliday isn't your guy.

 

[cobalt_27]

Don't do it. If you want a big bat in a points league Holliday isn't your guy.

 

[courduroy]

Agreed. Holliday won't give you the production you are looking for in any greater extent then Bossman will this season./

 

[Jason Wood]

Concur. Way too much to give up in a points league for Holliday.