Trade Advice (1 Viewer)

[TBam]

16 team Yahoo league, head to head weekly lineups.

I give:

Halladay

Mariano Rivera

I get:

Strasburg

Capps

Jay Bruce

I just lost Manny to the DL and have been struggling to get consistent power most of the year.

Here is my roster:

Mauer C

Adrian Gonzo 1B

Helton

Kelly Johnson 2B

Miguel Tejada 3B

Casey Blake

Cristian Guzman SS

Bay OF

Boesch OF

Nayjer Morgan OF

Jason Kuebel DH

Rajai Davis (replace Manny)

Manny Rameirz DL

Halladay

Romero

Leake

Burnett

Correia

Rivera

Nunez

Gregerson (holds)

O'Day (holds)

12 CATS total:

avg

ops

runs

hr

sb

rbi

w

h

s

k

whip

era

Thanks for any input.

 

[the moops]

have been struggling to get consistent power most of the year.

Jay Bruce is the opposite of consistent power.

 

[TBam]

have been struggling to get consistent power most of the year.

Jay Bruce is the opposite of consistent power.

Being a Reds fan I agree with this totally, but he would be an extra "throw in" and I could very easily cut Davis since I just grabbed him and Coco is back.

 

[the moops]

have been struggling to get consistent power most of the year.

Jay Bruce is the opposite of consistent power.

Being a Reds fan I agree with this totally, but he would be an extra "throw in" and I could very easily cut Davis since I just grabbed him and Coco is back.

A throw in makes me think that you think that the rest of the trade is in your favor.It is not. Halliday and Rivera >>>>>>>>>>>> Strasburg and Capps (adding a throw in like Bruce doesnt come anywhere near making up for the difference, IMO).

 

[TBam]

have been struggling to get consistent power most of the year.

Jay Bruce is the opposite of consistent power.

Being a Reds fan I agree with this totally, but he would be an extra "throw in" and I could very easily cut Davis since I just grabbed him and Coco is back.

A throw in makes me think that you think that the rest of the trade is in your favor.It is not. Halliday and Rivera >>>>>>>>>>>> Strasburg and Capps (adding a throw in like Bruce doesnt come anywhere near making up for the difference, IMO).

I didn't think the trade was in my favor without Bruce or I would of just done it without getting a second opinion. We are sitting at 7th and 8th place with the top 6 making the playoffs. Thanks for the advice, reassured my original gut feeling of no.