Trade advice (1 Viewer)

[steener]

.5 PPR league

I trade Howard Cohen Dez Cobb

I get Ajayi Thielen Wright Lee

My rb are Freeman Howard Ingram Cohen 

WR are Benjamin Adams Dez Snead Cobb Watkins 

 

[wlwiles]

How deep is this league?   Sounds like an awful lot to give up just to get Ajayi.  I wouldnt do this deal, since Wright and Lee offer little to no benefit to you, and you're giving up a lot of receiving value in that deal to get nothing back there

 

[steener]

How deep is this league?   Sounds like an awful lot to give up just to get Ajayi.  I wouldnt do this deal, since Wright and Lee offer little to no benefit to you, and you're giving up a lot of receiving value in that deal to get nothing back there

I feel like I have good WR and ayaji is an upgrade to Howard IMO. Plus Thielen

 

[wlwiles]

I don't think the uptick in RB from Howard to Ajayi is worth giving up that much WR value.  If Bradford is going to be iffy all year with the knee then Thielen is nothing more than Cole Beasley. If you want to change it to something like Howard/Cohen/Cobb for Ajayi/Thielen then I'm ok with it.  As it stands now, you're depleting all your WR depth for not much gain at RB.

 

[steener]

Bump

 

[abosweiler]

RT what wlwiles commented.  Exactly.

Help me out?

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/760590-how-much-faab-on-henrybuck-whir/

 

[steener]

I don't think the uptick in RB from Howard to Ajayi is worth giving up that much WR value.  If Bradford is going to be iffy all year with the knee then Thielen is nothing more than Cole Beasley. If you want to change it to something like Howard/Cohen/Cobb for Ajayi/Thielen then I'm ok with it.  As it stands now, you're depleting all your WR depth for not much gain at RB.

Why about this new offer, I give Howard/cohen, Kelvin Cobb 

id get Ayaji White Thielen Lee

 

[wlwiles]

Why about this new offer, I give Howard/cohen, Kelvin Cobb 

id get Ayaji White Thielen Lee

Again, I think it's depleting your WR depth for not much gain at RB.  Can you afford to give up Kelvin and Cobb?  Yes, because you're left with Dez, Snead, and Adams.  But it's a poor use of your WR depth in my opinion.  I realize you're going to be getting back Thielen and Lee, but you're never going to use them and they're not going to replenish your depth with enough value so that you can make a second "WR depth for stud" type trade a second time.  I just don't feel like you're getting enough bang for the buck out of that trade.  This trade doesn't need to be 4 for 4, make it 2 for 2 (Howard/Dez for Ajayi/Thielen) or 3 for 2 (Howard/Cohen/Cobb for Ayaji/Thielen) if you want but I can't see a reason why it needs to be such a big trade.  

I've got a league where I'm loaded at RB.  Have Lynch as my RB4, Carson and Martin as 5 and 6.  I'm not going to give up Lynch and Martin just so I can upgrade a WR from Cooper to AJ Green.  That's equivalent to what you're talking about doing.   

 

[Trelocke]

^ On point with his advice.