Trade Buck/Thielen for Kamara/Amendola? (1 Viewer)

[abosweiler]

PPR, 1-keeper. 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 2FLEX, 1TE

QB: Watson, RWilson

RB: McCoy, Buck, Ellington, Henry

WR: Odell (may stash for 2018 2nd round keeper), Hopkins, Cooper, Benjamin, Thielen

TE: Kelce

Do I upgrade trading Buck/Thielen for Kamara/Amendola?

Buck has toughest schedule vs RBs. Thielen has toughest schedule vs WRs.  Buck also scares me with Collins, and Woodhead possible to return later.  Thielen has QB issues.

Kamara has 6th easiest schedule vs RBs. Amendola has 7th easiest schedule vs WRs. No more Peterson for Kamara, not that he was competition.  Amendola seems to be the new underneath blanket for Brady.

Thoughts? WHIR.

 

[jmble]

Tough call.  Very close.  I like Kamara long term better than Buck.  

I like Thielen a lot but I like Brady much better than whoever QBs the Vikings.  I think that gives an edge to Amendola.

I think I like the Kamara/Amendola side of the deal better.  But it's really close.  

 

[beerbuff]

Amendola is so injury prone you can't count on him but also Woodhead could kill Allen so that's a wash. However since this is dynasty I'd be all over Kamara, I'd do it.

 

[Spectrum]

Similar to your other thread, I'd take it. Kamara's value will prob only go up. Buck Allen, while it's encouraging he could be a more dominant presence with T. West fading and Flacco back to full strength, Woodhead is still there and I don't see Buck as a RB2 kind of guy. Kamara I can def see as a RB1 end of this year or next. Amendola is too injury prone to get in a trade. Someone will drop him here and there.

If possible, maybe he'll take Benjamin instead of Thielen?

 

[Elevencents]

Kamara is the prize here. Do it. 

 

[Disposable Hero]

I would make the deal.