Trade Help (1 Viewer)

[BoomBoom]

5x5, 10 team roto league.

Being offered:

Berkman, Rich Hill, and Saito

for

Konerko, Matt Cain, and Borowski.

-

Torn on this one because I think Berkman will outperform Konerko over the course of the year, and Borowski is a lot shakier than Saito at closer. Broxton is on another team so no handcuff there, but I think Saito should keep the job this year as his stuff is filthy. Hill has a lot of upside, but I think Cain might be better this year, and right now he's pretty much my 2nd most reliable starter.

The rest of my pitching staff:

Johan, Snell, Javy Vazquez, Patterson, Anthony Reyes, Escobar

RP: Chad Cordero, Fuentes, Borowski, Weathers, Dotel

Any help or thoughts would be appreciated!

 

[D-BO]

I take this deal, upgrade everywhere except Cain but Hill is looking good. Saito is money.

 

[Ed Wood]

I'd do this deal. The SP is the only spot you don't gain...and you just might gain there too. Borowski's hold on the closer's job could become tenuous.

 

[my man otis]

I'd do it also.

Berkman > Konerko and Saito > Borowski.

I think Cain is better than Hill, but both are not that proven anyway.