Trade- Henry for McCaffrey (1 Viewer)

[Chadstroma]

Do I accept an offer where I give up Derrick Henry and a 2nd for Christian McCaffrey and a 3rd?

 

[Gally]

Is this is a PPR?  Are there any keeper restrictions (salary, round lost, keeper length, etc)?

Those matter but in a vacuum I think I would rather have Henry.

 

[Chadstroma]

Is this is a PPR?  Are there any keeper restrictions (salary, round lost, keeper length, etc)?

Those matter but in a vacuum I think I would rather have Henry.

It is PPR and it is a full dynasty league with fairly deep rosters.

 

[Gally]

It is PPR and it is a full dynasty league with fairly deep rosters.

In a PPR then I probably swing over to the McCaffrey side.  We saw what McCaffrey will be as a PPR asset and I don't see that changing.  Henry has the higher ceiling but a much lower floor.  I like the higher floor of McCaffrey at this point.  If I knew what the Titans were going to do with Murray that may change my mind back to Henry. 

Bottom line it's a very fair deal and really depends on your personal preference.  I could argue it either way.

 

[Chadstroma]

In a PPR then I probably swing over to the McCaffrey side.  We saw what McCaffrey will be as a PPR asset and I don't see that changing.  Henry has the higher ceiling but a much lower floor.  I like the higher floor of McCaffrey at this point.  If I knew what the Titans were going to do with Murray that may change my mind back to Henry. 

Bottom line it's a very fair deal and really depends on your personal preference.  I could argue it either way.

I also like Turner as OC there for McCaffrey since Turner is historically RB friendly.

 

[fightingillini]

It's a fair deal, and I would prefer the McCaffrey side in a PPR league.