Trade review (1 Viewer)

[Steve111]

opinions please.....

12 team PPR. My team:

QB-Allen, Newton

RB-Fournette, Kerryon Johnson, Mostert, Tarik Cohen

WR-Davante Adam's, OBJ, Tyrell William's, Mike William's, DeSean Jackson

TE- OJ Howard, Vance McDonald

Give - Odell Beckham, Fournette, Vance McDonald

Get - McCaffrey, Edelman, Delanie Walker

 

[sassytaco23]

I wouldn't do it. Antonio could be far too risky and Lindsay is splitting work. You can find a better trade. Mine is: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/780351-trade-devonta-freeman-for-brandin-cooks/

 

[Gally]

I wouldn't do it. Antonio could be far too risky and Lindsay is splitting work. You can find a better trade. Mine is: https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/780351-trade-devonta-freeman-for-brandin-cooks/

Where are Lindsay and Antonio in this deal?

Tough to give a proper evaluation when I don't know the rosters, starting requirements, league type/scoring (PPR?), etc.

In a vacuum I would probably rather keep the OBJ side because I am worried about CMC since Newton looks to be on the shelf for awhile.  Without Cam drawing attention defenses will load up on CMC and he is likely to be hampered by that. 

 

[Steve111]

Where are Lindsay and Antonio in this deal?

Tough to give a proper evaluation when I don't know the rosters, starting requirements, league type/scoring (PPR?), etc.

In a vacuum I would probably rather keep the OBJ side because I am worried about CMC since Newton looks to be on the shelf for awhile.  Without Cam drawing attention defenses will load up on CMC and he is likely to be hampered by that. 

Added my roster

 

[Gally]

Added my roster

Tough choice.  Really fair deal to me.  I think I lean to CMC due to the PPR format.