Using a 3 year window, who's Dynasty #5 RB (1 Viewer)

[bigreese82]

In a startup dynasty...who's number 5 rb ppr?

top 4 are assumed to be LT, LJ, SA, and Portis

using a 3 year window

 

[nygiants56]

Jordan and Jackson don't belong on this list, IMO..both have big questions..

Jackson has the biggest sponsor of RBBC in the NFL, head coach Scott Linehan.

he'll use faulk till he drops dead,cutting into sjax's totals for 2006..

but even looking forward,Linehan will still use rbbc, so I see no reason for Jackson to be considered as a top 5 keeper at RB..

Jordan averaged 3.8 per carry..thats pathetic. Art Shell returns as HC, after being out of the game for a long time.took Joe GIbbs some time to get re-acquianted to the NFL, I suppose it will take Shell some time too..new offense,new coaches, etc..alot of unknowns at least for 2006..

Caddy is definitely a potentil top 5 guy the next 3 years, as is Cedrick Benson , who plays in a offense that utilizes the same style of play as the KC Chiefs use, similar to what Norv Turner ran in Dallas with Emmitt..i.e., plenty of chances for Rb's to carry the load and plenty of scoring opportunities..

brian griese makes chicago better, a lot better..TJ won the starting role in 2005 by default,b/c Benson held out and gift-wrapped that starting gig to him..

this year, Chicago is talking about open competition for the starting role..Benson should pass TJ at some point in training camp, and never look back..

 

[Assani Fisher]

Bush

 

[Iron_Far]

Bush

 

[mbuehner]

brian griese makes chicago better, a lot better

Not standing on the sideline he wont.

..TJ won the starting role in 2005 by default,b/c Benson held out and gift-wrapped that starting gig to him..

True- which begs the question why did Benson do that? And will he continue to be a headcase and talk himself out of playing time? Furthermore just because Benson took himself out of contention by no means proves he would have won out in a straight up competition. The team loves Jones and the versatility he brings to the offense. Here's a guy that accounted for almost 1500 yards and 9 tds in 15 games on an offense that looked like it was playing back in the pre-forward pass era. Jones should not be dismissed out of hand.

this year, Chicago is talking about open competition for the starting role..Benson should pass TJ at some point in training camp, and never look back..

A lot of people should do a lot of things but it doesnt always happen that way. I would highly surprised if Benson was named the starter before the season so long as TJ stays healthy. Best case for Benson he eats into carries more and more as the season progresses until he is 1A in a RBBC situation. Jones' passcatching and homerun breaking ability are going to be critical for this offense.

 

[bigreese82]

Jordan and Jackson don't belong on this list, IMO..both have big questions..

Jackson has the biggest sponsor of RBBC in the NFL, head coach Scott Linehan.

he'll use faulk till he drops dead,cutting into sjax's totals for 2006..

but even looking forward,Linehan will still use rbbc, so I see no reason for Jackson to be considered as a top 5 keeper at RB..

Jordan averaged 3.8 per carry..thats pathetic. Art Shell returns as HC, after being out of the game for a long time.took Joe GIbbs some time to get re-acquianted to the NFL, I suppose it will take Shell some time too..new offense,new coaches, etc..alot of unknowns at least for 2006..

Caddy is definitely a potentil top 5 guy the next 3 years, as is Cedrick Benson , who plays in a offense that utilizes the same style of play as the KC Chiefs use, similar to what Norv Turner ran in Dallas with Emmitt..i.e., plenty of chances for Rb's to carry the load and plenty of scoring opportunities..

brian griese makes chicago better, a lot better..TJ won the starting role in 2005 by default,b/c Benson held out and gift-wrapped that starting gig to him..

this year, Chicago is talking about open competition for the starting role..Benson should pass TJ at some point in training camp, and never look back..

I definitely think Jackson belongs on the list and Jordan has proved he's a 3 down backThought EDGE would get more votes...noone will steal carries