Variable Keeper Question (1 Viewer)

[Keith R]

Basics;  

Non-PPR, draft is 20 rounds.

Whomever I keep in 2019 will be a free agent in 2020.

Each team can only keep ONE player.

The cost of the keeper is one round higher than the round they went for last year (so last year's 1st rounders cannot be kept).  Free agents are treated as 10th round picks.

My choices;

Juju Smith-Schuster 3.06

Phillip Lindsay 9.06

Jameis Winston 14.07 (my co-owner likes this pick; otherwise I would not have included him)

Tyrell Williams 19.06

TIA

 

[wlwiles]

Lindsay is the obvious choice to me. Jameis is meh, lots of other QBs that are better, and Tyrell is a complete unknown on a new team with an iffy QB.  Juju is a second round ADP but Lindsay is the better value. 

If it’s a 2QB league then Jameis makes a little more sense but I still would go Lindsay. 

 

[jwsbowler]

For me, I am keeping JuJu.  Lindsay's injury pushes me away from him.

 

[Keith R]

Thanks, Guys.

That is my primary debate - the value of Lindsay vs the risk of the injury.  JuJu I like a lot but the value is only a round or so.  The other two are outliers.  Totally agree with the QB situation.  Williams is a bit intriguing only because he is so cheap.

 

[Skoo]

I'd go with JuJu.

As others have said, Lindsay has a lot of variables that could work against him. But as long as he's healthy, JuJu should be an absolute lock to finish as a WR1, with upside to be a Top 3 WR.

If ya don't mind:

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/777917-keepers-because-apparently-i-run-my-wifes-team/

 

[Gally]

With only one keeper I usually just keep the best player.  For that i would just take JuJu and be done.