Mathews college coaches made comments that he routinely pulled himself out of games for various minor injuries.
Also, how many times has he been listed as questionable since entering the league?
Here are his injuries through 2 seasons that he missed or left early from games:
Clavicle week 1+ 12'
Calf soreness week 17. 11'
Knee soreness week 12. 11'
Groin soreness. Weeks 8-11. 11'
Thumb injury. Week 7 11'
Calf week 5. 11'
Wrist week 5 11'
Foot. Week 3. 11'
Upper leg strain. Preseason. 11'
Toe. Preseason. 11'
Failed conditioning test. 11'
Wrist. Week 17'. 10
Calf. Week 16. 10'
Ankle. Weeks 9-13. 10'
Facial laceration. Week 8. 10'
Ankle. Weeks 2-7. 10'
Elbow. Week 3
nose bleeds. Preseason. 10'
So as you can see. I'm not making up his uncanny ability to be on the injury report and miss playing time virtually every week.
Just because he's in the NFL doesn't grant him a high pain tolerance.
Hijack noted
Continued hijack warning!1)Clavicle week 1+ 12'-
Technically has not missed any reg. season games yet so let's leave that for now
Calf soreness week 17. 11'-
Missed last game of season for team already eliminated from playoffs and no FF implications for most
2)Knee soreness week 12. 11'-
He had 142 total yards and 1 reception. So how early did he leave? Did he come back in the game? Regardless that's good production.
3)Groin soreness. Weeks 8-11. 11'-
He got hurt in week 8, missed week 9, and was limited in weeks 10 and 11. Bad stretch but most RBs with a bad groin are going to miss time and/or produce in a subpar fashion.
Thumb injury. Week 7 11'-
65 total yards, 4 receptions. Bad week, salvageable in PPR
4)Calf week 5. 11'-
Had 132 total yards and 1 reception. Again good production. How early did he leave? Did he return to the game.
5)Wrist week 5 11'-
Same week as above. Same production same question.
6)Foot. Week 3. 11'-
Had 149 yards, 2 TDs, and 4 receptions. GREAT production. How early did he leave? Did he return to the game?
7)Upper leg strain. Preseason. 11'-
Preseason, couldn't care less.
8)Toe. Preseason. 11'-
Preseason, couldn't care less.
9)Failed conditioning test. 11'-
See above
10)Wrist. Week 17'. 10-
Had 139 yards and 3 TDs. Great production. To be fair, no FF implications for most. But when did he leave game? Did he return?
11)Calf. Week 16. 10'-
83 Total yards, 1 TD, 3 receptions. Solid FF production.
12)Ankle. Weeks 9-13. 10'-
Got hurt in week 9 and missed next 3 games.
13)Facial laceration. Week 8. 10'-
54 total yards, 1 TD, 3 receptions. Solid production.
14)Ankle. Weeks 2-7. 10'-
Got hurt week 2, missed week 3, played weeks 3-7 with subpar production.
15)Elbow. Week 3-
I'm assuming this is 2010. Missed week 3, not sure if it was ankle or elbow
16) nose bleeds. Preseason. 10'-
Preseason
So of the 15 injuries you list before the clavicle, 4 were in the pre-season and include failing a conditioning test, some overlap the same weeks, and he produced 8 games of solid to very good FF production.
I won't argue that he's had more than his share of injuries. But I don't see how you call a guy soft when he's still played and produced FF wise with 8 of the 11 reg. season injuries you mentioned. That's what I'm interested in. His FF production.
You talk about him missing time every week and leaving games early. How much time is he missing? How many times is he leaving these games and not returning? How do you characterize his ability to still produce when doing these things? Without having definitive answers to the above or being a trainer on the sideline how do you have ANY idea of what his pain tolerance is?
Bottom line for me is the guy has had more than his share of injuries but STILL finished as RB7 last year AND sharing touches with Tolbert. I attribute his injuries to bad luck and having to learn how to better condition himself. I'm not going to sit on my keyboard and guess at his level of pain tolerance. It's football, guys get hurt. Mathews has gotten hurt more than his fair share over his young career. But he's still played in 81% of the reg. season games of his 2 year career. He's still produced while sharing a lot of touches with Tolbert. I'll let you and others assume you know his pain tolerance and make jokes. I'll just take a gamble on his FF production.